2012


Public Decisions Summary


 

 Removals in 2012 

 No Records Found 


 

 Suspensions in 2012 

 No Records Found 


 

 Censures in 2012 

Case Number Judge(s) Complainant(s) Disposition Type Description
2012-177 Cornelio, Carmine
Watters, Andrea
Formal Sanctions Censured

 

 Reprimands in 2012 

Case Number Judge(s) Complainant(s) Disposition Type Description
2012-315 Goetteman, Gary
Cahill, Judge Peter
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-308 Segal, Anne Fisher
Ortiz, Ivo
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-300 Madden, Sheila A.
Self-report,Judge
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-282 Peterson, Fred L.
Self-report, Judge
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-275 DeForest, Melanie
McMurry, Steven
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-266 DeForest, Melanie
Commission, Judicial Conduct
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-265 McClennen, Crane
Miller, Eleanor L.
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-263 Gottsfield, Robert L.
Catapano, John
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-261 Gunnels, Butch
Anonymous,
Grimsley, Hon. Donna
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-255 Basteen, John
Tucker, Steven
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-234 Bassett, Edward W.
Baker, Kim (Kimmie)
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-218 Barth, Keith
Commission, Judicial Conduct
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-197 Martinez, Marie
Mehrens, Jeffery
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-179 Martinez, Marie
Ambrose, Keith
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-178 Umphress, Jeanette
Self-report, Judge
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-176 Lodge, Joseph
Moran, Mark
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-135 King, Lawrence C.
Palmer, Mike
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-128 Segal, Anne Fisher
Self-report, Judge
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-118 Frankel, Keith
Karp, Ronald I.
Harris, Myra
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-104 Jayne, Clancy L.
Anonymous,
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-051 Woolbright, Phillip
Williams, Gerald
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-029 Lester, Michael A.
Osterfeld, David
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-012 Chiles, Mark
Herman, Laurie
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand

 

 Dismissals in 2012 

Case Number Disposition Type Description
2012-361 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-360 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-358 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-357 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-356 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-355 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-354 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-353 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-352 Dismissal with Comments Warning
2012-351 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-350 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-349 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-348 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-347 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-346 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-345 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-344 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-343 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-342 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-341 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-340 Dismissal Lack of jurisdiction
2012-339 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-338 Dismissal Lack of jurisdiction
2012-337 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-335 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-334 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-333 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-332 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-331 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-330 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-329 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-328 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-327 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-326 Dismissal Resigned while action pending
2012-325 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-324 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-323 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-322 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-321 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-320 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-319 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-318 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-317 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-316 Dismissal with Comments Warning
2012-314 Dismissal Lack of jurisdiction
2012-313 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-312 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-311 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-310 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-309 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-307 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-306 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-305 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-304 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-303 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-302 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-301 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-299 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-298 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-297 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-296 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-295 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-294 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-293 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-292 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-291 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-290 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-289 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-288 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-287 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-286 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-285 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-284 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-283 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-281 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-280 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-279 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-278 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-277 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-276 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-274 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-273 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-272 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-271 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-270 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-269 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-268 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-267 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-264 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-262 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-260 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-259 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-258 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-257 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-256 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-254 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-253 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-252 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-251 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-250 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-249 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-248 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-247 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-246 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-245 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-244 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-243 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-242 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-241 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-240 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-239 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-238 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-237 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-236 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-235 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-233 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-232 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-231 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-230 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-229 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-228 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-227 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-226 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-225 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-224 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-223 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-222 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-221 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-220 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-219 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-217 Dismissal Lack of jurisdiction
2012-216 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-215 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-214 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-213 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-212 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-211 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-210 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-209 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-208 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-207 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-206 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-205 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-204 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-203 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-202 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-201 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-200 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-199 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-198 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-196 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-195 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-194 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-193 Dismissal Lack of jurisdiction
2012-192 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-191 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-190 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-189 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-188 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-187 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-186 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-185 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-184 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-183 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-182 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-181 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-180 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-175 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-174 Dismissal with Comments Warning
2012-173 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-172 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-171 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-170 Dismissal Lack of jurisdiction
2012-169 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-168 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-167 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-166 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-165 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-164 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-163 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-162 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-161 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-160 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-159 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-158 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-157 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-156 Dismissal with Comments Warning
2012-155 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-154 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-153 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-152 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-151 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-150 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-149 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-148 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-147 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-146 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-145 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-144 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-143 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-142 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-141 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-140 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-139 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-138 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-137 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-136 Dismissal with Comments Warning
2012-134 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-133 Dismissal Retired while action pending
2012-132 Dismissal Insufficient evidence; unfounded
2012-131 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-130 Dismissal with Comments Warning
2012-129 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-127 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-126 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-125 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-124 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-123 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-122 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-121 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-120 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-119 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-117 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-116 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-115 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-114 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-113 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-112 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-111 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-110 Dismissal with Comments Warning
2012-109 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-108 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-107 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-106 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-105 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-103 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-102 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-101 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-100 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-099 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-098 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-097 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-096 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-095 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-094 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-093 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-092 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-091 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-090 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-089 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-088 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-087 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-086 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-085 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-084 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-083 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-082 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-081 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-080 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-079 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-078 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-077 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-076 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-075 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-074 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-073 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-072 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-071 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-070 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-069 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-068 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-067 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-066 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-065 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-064 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-063 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-062 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-061 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-060 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-059 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-058 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-057 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-056 Dismissal with Comments Warning
2012-055 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-054 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-053 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-052 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-050 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-049 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-048 Dismissal Insufficient evidence; unfounded
2012-047 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-046 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-045 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-044 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-043 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-042 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-041 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-040 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-039 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-038 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-037 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-036 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-035 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-034 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-033 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-032 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-031 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-030 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-028 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-027 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-026 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-025 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-024 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-023 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-022 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-021 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-020 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-019 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-018 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-017 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-016 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-015 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-014 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-013 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-011 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-010 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-009 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-008 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-007 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-006 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-005 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-004 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-003 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-002 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-001 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation