Search 

Commission on Judicial Conduct

2012

Public Decisions Summary


 

 Removals in 2012 

 No Records Found 


 

 Suspensions in 2012 

 No Records Found 


 

 Censures in 2012 

Case Number Judge(s) Complainant(s) Disposition Type Description
2012-177 Cornelio, Carmine
Watters, Andrea
Formal Sanctions Censured

 

 Reprimands in 2012 

Case Number Judge(s) Complainant(s) Disposition Type Description
2012-315 Goetteman, Gary
Cahill, Judge Peter
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-308 Segal, Anne Fisher
Ortiz, Ivo
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-300 Madden, Sheila A.
Self-report,Judge
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-282 Peterson, Fred L.
Self-report, Judge
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-275 DeForest, Melanie
McMurry, Steven
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-266 DeForest, Melanie
Commission, Judicial Conduct
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-265 McClennen, Crane
Miller, Eleanor L.
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-263 Gottsfield, Robert L.
Catapano, John
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-261 Gunnels, Butch
Anonymous,
Grimsley, Hon. Donna
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-255 Basteen, John
Tucker, Steven
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-234 Bassett, Edward W.
Baker, Kim (Kimmie)
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-218 Barth, Keith
Commission, Judicial Conduct
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-197 Martinez, Marie
Mehrens, Jeffery
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-179 Martinez, Marie
Ambrose, Keith
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-178 Umphress, Jeanette
Self-report, Judge
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-176 Lodge, Joseph
Moran, Mark
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-135 King, Lawrence C.
Palmer, Mike
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-128 Segal, Anne Fisher
Self-report, Judge
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-118 Frankel, Keith
Karp, Ronald I.
Harris, Myra
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-104 Jayne, Clancy L.
Anonymous,
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-051 Woolbright, Phillip
Williams, Gerald
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-029 Lester, Michael A.
Osterfeld, David
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand
2012-012 Chiles, Mark
Herman, Laurie
Informal Sanctions Public reprimand

 

 Dismissals in 2012 

Case Number Disposition Type Description
2012-361 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-360 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-358 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-357 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-356 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-355 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-354 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-353 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-352 Dismissal with Comments Warning
2012-351 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-350 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-349 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-348 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-347 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-346 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-345 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-344 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-343 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-342 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-341 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-340 Dismissal Lack of jurisdiction
2012-339 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-338 Dismissal Lack of jurisdiction
2012-337 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-335 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-334 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-333 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-332 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-331 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-330 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-329 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-328 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-327 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-326 Dismissal Resigned while action pending
2012-325 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-324 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-323 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-322 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-321 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-320 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-319 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-318 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-317 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-316 Dismissal with Comments Warning
2012-314 Dismissal Lack of jurisdiction
2012-313 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-312 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-311 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-310 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-309 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-307 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-306 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-305 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-304 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-303 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-302 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-301 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-299 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-298 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-297 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-296 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-295 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-294 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-293 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-292 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-291 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-290 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-289 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-288 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-287 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-286 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-285 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-284 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-283 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-281 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-280 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-279 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-278 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-277 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-276 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-274 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-273 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-272 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-271 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-270 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-269 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-268 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-267 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-264 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-262 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-260 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-259 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-258 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-257 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-256 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-254 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-253 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-252 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-251 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-250 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-249 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-248 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-247 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-246 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-245 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-244 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-243 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-242 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-241 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-240 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-239 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-238 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-237 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-236 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-235 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-233 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-232 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-231 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-230 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-229 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-228 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-227 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-226 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-225 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-224 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-223 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-222 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-221 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-220 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-219 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-217 Dismissal Lack of jurisdiction
2012-216 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-215 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-214 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-213 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-212 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-211 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-210 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-209 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-208 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-207 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-206 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-205 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-204 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-203 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-202 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-201 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-200 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-199 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-198 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-196 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-195 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-194 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-193 Dismissal Lack of jurisdiction
2012-192 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-191 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-190 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-189 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-188 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-187 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-186 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-185 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-184 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-183 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-182 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-181 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-180 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-175 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-174 Dismissal with Comments Warning
2012-173 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-172 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-171 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-170 Dismissal Lack of jurisdiction
2012-169 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-168 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-167 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-166 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-165 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-164 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-163 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-162 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-161 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-160 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-159 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-158 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-157 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-156 Dismissal with Comments Warning
2012-155 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-154 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-153 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-152 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-151 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-150 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-149 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-148 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-147 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-146 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-145 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-144 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-143 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-142 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-141 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-140 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-139 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-138 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-137 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-136 Dismissal with Comments Warning
2012-134 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-133 Dismissal Retired while action pending
2012-132 Dismissal Insufficient evidence; unfounded
2012-131 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-130 Dismissal with Comments Warning
2012-129 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-127 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-126 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-125 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-124 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-123 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-122 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-121 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-120 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-119 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-117 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-116 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-115 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-114 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-113 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-112 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-111 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-110 Dismissal with Comments Warning
2012-109 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-108 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-107 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-106 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-105 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-103 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-102 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-101 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-100 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-099 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-098 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-097 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-096 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-095 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-094 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-093 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-092 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-091 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-090 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-089 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-088 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-087 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-086 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-085 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-084 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-083 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-082 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-081 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-080 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-079 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-078 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-077 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-076 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-075 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-074 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-073 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-072 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-071 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-070 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-069 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-068 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-067 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-066 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-065 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-064 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-063 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-062 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-061 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-060 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-059 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-058 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-057 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-056 Dismissal with Comments Warning
2012-055 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-054 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-053 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-052 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-050 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-049 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-048 Dismissal Insufficient evidence; unfounded
2012-047 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-046 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-045 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-044 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-043 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-042 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-041 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-040 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-039 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-038 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-037 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-036 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-035 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-034 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-033 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-032 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-031 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-030 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-028 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-027 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-026 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-025 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-024 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-023 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-022 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-021 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-020 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-019 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-018 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-017 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-016 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-015 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-014 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-013 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-011 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-010 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-009 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-008 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation
2012-007 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-006 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-005 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-004 Dismissal with Comments Advisory letter
2012-003 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-002 Dismissal Legal or appellate issues
2012-001 Dismissal No misconduct; no violation