Search 

Court of Appeals

Division One

Search filter ON - Top 1000 records found    Clear search filter
Judge: Portley, Maurice
Search Decisions

12345678910...
9/1/2015   1 CA-CV 13-0665NEWMAN v. SELECTOPINION
 John C. Gemmill, Author; Kenton D. Jones, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

 
  1. Does the “Barassi exception” to the finality requirement for appeals breathe life into the Hospital’s premature notice of appeal?

  2. Should the trial court have sent the issue of punitive damages to the jury for determination?

  3. Which Adult Protective Services Act (“APSA”) attorney fee provision was applicable:  the fee statute in effect at the time of the liability creating conduct, the fee statute in effect when the action was filed in superior court, or the fee statute in effect when the judgment was rendered?

  4. Did the superior court abuse its discretion or commit legal error in awarding $112,500 in attorney fees to plaintiff’s counsel instead of the greater amount requested?

  5. Does the APSA provision, § 46-455(H)(4), authorize a greater award of costs than § 12-332?

9/1/2015   1 CA-SA 15-0150SPERO v. HON. HERROD/SPEROMEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; Michael J. Brown, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

8/27/2015   1 CA-CV 14-0222PRESTON et al. v. AMADEIOPINION
 Michael J. Brown, Author; Maurice Portley, Concur; John C. Gemmill, Concur

 

1.   Is a medical expert witness qualified to testify under A.R.S. § 12-2604 when the prospective expert witness and the defendant treating physician are both board-certified in the same specialty (internal medicine), but the expert witness practices exclusively in a subspecialty (cardiology) not practiced by the defendant physician?

2.  Is a defendant physician entitled to substitute an expert witness under A.R.S. § 12-2603 when his or her timely disclosed expert witness has been disqualified under A.R.S. § 12-2604?

3.  May a plaintiff whose complaint frames only a claim for medical malpractice introduce evidence that the defendant physician's care violated his employment contract?

4.  Did the trial court abuse its discretion in imposing attorneys' fees as a sanction when plaintiff erroneously disclosed that the medical examiner would testify at trial contrary to his autopsy report and the death certificate?

5.   Did the trial court err in concluding that plaintiff’s expert witness was qualified to testify under Arizona Rule of Evidence 702 regarding his opinions as to the treatment a patient would have received and the likely outcome of that treatment based on his years of experience in a medical practice?

8/27/2015   1 CA-CV 13-0625JOHNSON v. SWINGMEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; John C. Gemmill, Concur; Jon W. Thompson, Concur

8/27/2015   1 CA-CR 14-0611STATE v. GORMANMEMORANDUM
  1 CA-CR 14-0619STATE v. GORMAN
 Maurice Portley, Author; John C. Gemmill, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

8/25/2015   1 CA-CV 14-0185RITCHIE v. COSTELLO et al.OPINION
 Maurice Portley, Author; John C. Gemmill, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

 Does a municipality that owns an uncontrolled airport and is hosting a hot air balloon festival have a duty to a powered paraglider after it leaves the airfield and is flying around taking pictures?
8/20/2015   1 CA-TX 14-0005HUB v. MARICOPA/ADOROPINION
 Patricia A. Orozco, Author; Randall M. Howe, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

 

Whether the Property is exempt from property tax assessment because it was owned by the City of Phoenix during the assessment period, for the tax year 2011. 

Whether the Property  was subject to double taxation because the City of Phoenix could have been required to pay government property lease excise taxes, pursuant to Arizona Revised Statute section 14-6203.G. 

8/13/2015   1 CA-CR 14-0165STATE v. CAHILLMEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; John C. Gemmill, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

8/13/2015   1 CA-CR 14-0757STATE v. GOLLIHARMEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; Patricia K. Norris, Concur; Patricia A. Orozco, Concur

8/13/2015   1 CA-CV 14-0344CHAVIRA v. ARMOROPINION
 Maurice Portley, Author; John C. Gemmill, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

 Can a licensed contractor who does both licensed and unlicensed work on a project, recover payment for the licensed work completed under A.R.S. § 32-1153?
8/13/2015   1 CA-CV 14-0123FIRST FINANCIAL v. CLAASSENOPINION
 Jon W. Thompson, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

 Whether, for deficiency judgment purposes, interest, loan fees, and a homeowner's association construction deposit constitute purchase money obligations.
8/4/2015   1 CA-CR 14-0731STATE v. MENDIOLAMEMORANDUM
 John C. Gemmill, Author; Maurice Portley, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

8/4/2015   1 CA-CR 14-0373STATE v. SANCHEZMEMORANDUM
 John C. Gemmill; Maurice Portley, Concur; Patricia A. Orozco, Concur

8/4/2015   1 CA-CV 13-0716-FCVASQUEZ-ARAIZA v. GURROLAMEMORANDUM
 Lawrence F. Winthrop, Author; Kent E. Cattani, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

8/4/2015   1 CA-CR 14-0451STATE v. CERVANTESMEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; John C. Gemmill, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

7/30/2015   1 CA-CR 14-0539STATE v. HASSANMEMORANDUM
 John C. Gemmill, Author; Maurice Portley, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

7/30/2015   1 CA-JV 15-0011ANGELIQUE B. v. DCS, et al.MEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; John C. Gemmill, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

7/30/2015   1 CA-CR 14-0156STATE v. VINCENTMEMORANDUM
  1 CA-CR 14-0636STATE v. VINCENT
 Patricia A. Orozco, Author; Patricia K. Norris, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

7/30/2015   1 CA-JV 14-0182TERISA C., LAWRENCE E. v. DCS, et al.MEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Jon W. Thompson, Concur

7/28/2015   1 CA-JV 15-0061STEPHANIE M. v. DCS, A.M.MEMORANDUM
 Patricia A. Orozco, Author; Patricia K. Norris, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

7/23/2015   1 CA-JV 14-0336KARLI B. v. DCS, et al.MEMORANDUM
 Patricia A. Orozco, Author; Patricia K. Norris, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

7/23/2015   1 CA-CR 14-0085STATE v. LEKERMEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Jon W. Thompson, Concur

7/23/2015   1 CA-CR 14-0551STATE v. MCPHERSONMEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; John C. Gemmill, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

7/23/2015   1 CA-CR 14-0428STATE v. HARRISMEMORANDUM
 Patricia K. Norris, Author; Patricia A. Orozco, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

7/23/2015   1 CA-SA 14-0214STATE v. HON. STEINLE/MORANOPINION
 Patricia A. Orozco, Author; Maurice Portley, Concur; Randall M. Howe, Dissent

 

1.  Whether Arizona Rule of Evidence 106 applies to conduct.

2.  Whether admission of a complete video is necessary to put events into context and avoid undue prejudice.  

7/21/2015   1 CA-JV 14-0271ROSABELLE P., ARTEM D. v. DCS et al.MEMORANDUM
 Patricia K. Norris, Author; Patricia A. Orozco, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

7/21/2015   1 CA-CR 14-0531STATE v. VALENZUELAMEMORANDUM
 Patricia K. Norris, Author; Patricia A. Orozco, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

7/16/2015   1 CA-CR 14-0280STATE v. MURRIETAMEMORANDUM
 Patricia K. Norris, Author; Patricia A. Orozco, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

7/9/2015   1 CA-CR 14-0386STATE v. ESTRADAMEMORANDUM
 John C. Gemmill, Author; Maurice Portley, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

7/9/2015   1 CA-CR 14-0691STATE v. BACAMEMORANDUM
 Michael J. Brown, Author; Maurice Portley, Concur; John C. Gemmill, Concur

7/7/2015   1 CA-CR 14-0458STATE v. CHURCHMEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Jon W. Thompson, Concur

7/2/2015   1 CA-CR 14-0209STATE v. SWIERMEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Jon W. Thompson, Concur

7/2/2015   1 CA-CR 14-0746STATE v. CLITSOMEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; John C. Gemmill, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

6/30/2015   1 CA-CR 13-0304STATE v. HAYESMEMORANDUM
 Michael J. Brown, Author; Maurice Portley, Concur; John C. Gemmill, Concur

6/30/2015   1 CA-CR 13-0927 PRPCSTATE v. MOYAMEMORANDUM
 Michael J. Brown, Author; Maurice Portley, Concur; John C. Gemmill, Concur

6/30/2015   1 CA-CV 14-0501HEUSCHKEL v. BERGMANN et al.MEMORANDUM
 John C. Gemmill, Author; Maurice Portley, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

6/30/2015   1 CA-CV 14-0559OLARIU v. GIBBONS et al.MEMORANDUM
 John C. Gemmill, Author; Maurice Portley, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

6/25/2015   1 CA-CR 14-0203STATE v. LANDRUMMEMORANDUM
 Jon W. Thompson, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

6/25/2015   1 CA-CV 14-0075ORIGAMI et al. v. CONNELLYMEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Jon W. Thompson, Concur

6/25/2015   1 CA-CV 14-0563MOORE v. BREWER COTEMEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; John C. Gemmill, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

6/25/2015   1 CA-CV 14-0575 FCHITT v. HITTMEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; John C. Gemmill, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

6/25/2015   1 CA-JV 14-0182TERISA C., LAWRENCE E. v. DCS, et al.MEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Jon W. Thompson, Concur

6/23/2015   1 CA-CV 14-0027UNITED, et al. v. MIHSOPINION
  1 CA-CV 14-0421UNITED, et al. v. MIHS
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Maurice Portley, Concur; Jon W. Thompson, Concur

 

Whether a party may compel arbitration pursuant to an arbitration agreement for a claim involving coverage under a Medicare or ERISA health care plan.

6/23/2015   1 CA-CV 14-0058ALLEN v. SCF/MORRISMEMORANDUM
 Jon W. Thompson, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

6/16/2015   1 CA-CV 14-0229TAYLOR v. APSMEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Jon W. Thompson, Concur

6/11/2015   1 CA-CR 14-0370STATE v. SANCHEZMEMORANDUM
 Jon W. Thompson, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

6/9/2015   1 CA-CR 13-0765 PRPCSTATE v. BUSTOSMEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; John C. Gemmill, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

6/9/2015   1 CA-CR 13-0923 PRPCSTATE v. REYESMEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; John C. Gemmill, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

6/9/2015   1 CA-CR 14-0274STATE v. BREENMEMORANDUM
 Jon W. Thompson, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

6/9/2015   1 CA-JV 14-0329JESSICA C. v. DCS, et al.MEMORANDUM
  1 CA-JV 14-0331JESSICA C. v. DCS, et al.
 Maurice Portley, Author; John C. Gemmill, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

12345678910...