Search 

Court of Appeals

Division One

Search filter ON - Top 1000 records found    Clear search filter
Judge: Downie, Margaret H.
Search Decisions

12345678910...
9/29/2016   1 CA-CV 15-0387-FCGUAJARDO v. GRAVESMEMORANDUM
 Patricia K. Norris, Author; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

9/27/2016   1 CA-CR 14-0661-PRPCSTATE v. KEITHMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Patricia K. Norris, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

9/27/2016   1 CA-CR 14-0609-PRPCSTATE v. ORDUNOMEMORANDUM
 Patricia K. Norris, Author; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

9/22/2016   1 CA-CR 13-0895STATE v. MARTINSONOPINION
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; John C. Gemmill, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

 

1.      Whether the State’s decision to charge the defendant with felony murder, relying on child abuse as the predicate offense, precluded prosecutors from presenting evidence and argument at trial that the defendant intended to kill the victim.

2.      Whether, notwithstanding error in precluding evidence of an intent to kill the victim, dismissal with prejudice was proper due to prosecutorial misconduct.

3.      Whether substantial evidence supported the guilty verdicts for felony murder and child abuse.

 
9/22/2016   1 CA-CR 14-0670-PRPCSTATE v. BRANCHMEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Patricia K. Norris, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

9/22/2016   1 CA-JV 16-0142IN RE CELESTINO S.MEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Patricia K. Norris, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

9/20/2016   1 CA-CR 16-0022STATE v. WHITLOCKMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Patricia K. Norris, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

9/20/2016   1 CA-JV 16-0028NICHOLAUS C. v. SARAH C., I.C.MEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Patricia K. Norris, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

9/20/2016   1 CA-CV 15-0530DCB v. FOREMAN et al. MEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Patricia K. Norris, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

9/20/2016   1 CA-JV 16-0099KENNETH A. v. DCS, K.A. MEMORANDUM
 Patricia K. Norris, Author; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

9/20/2016   1 CA-CV 15-0389AMERICAN et al. v. LOPEZMEMORANDUM
 Patricia K. Norris, Author; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

9/20/2016   1 CA-CR 15-0637STATE v. GILFILLANMEMORANDUM
 Patricia K. Norris, Author; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

9/15/2016   1 CA-CV 15-0553DENVER et al. v. AZCCMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Patricia K. Norris, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

9/15/2016   1 CA-JV 16-0141BELLA P. v. DCS, et al.MEMORANDUM
 Jon W. Thompson, Author; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

9/15/2016   1 CA-CR 15-0679STATE v. LYNAMMEMORANDUM
 Jon W. Thompson, Author; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

 Constitutionality Decision
This decision reaffirms the constitutionality of requiring a sentence of at least 10 years for the crime of sexual exploitation of a minor by the possession of child pornography, for each charged image of which the defendant is convicted, to be served consecutively pursuant to A.R.S. Sections 13-705(D), (M), -3551(12) and State v. Berger, 212 Ariz.473 (2006).  In accordance with Berger, we hold the requirements constitutional under the Eighth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.
9/8/2016   1 CA-CV 15-0772-FCMANOLA v. ESPINOZAMEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Jon W. Thompson, Concur

9/8/2016   1 CA-CR 15-0441STATE v. MORAGAMEMORANDUM
 Kent E. Cattani, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Donn Kessler, Concur

9/6/2016   1 CA-CR 14-0338-PRPCSTATE v. SANCHEZMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Patricia K. Norris, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

9/1/2016   1 CA-CR 14-0588-PRPCSTATE v. KAUL-AROBMEMORANDUM
 Patricia K. Norris, Author; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

8/30/2016   1 CA-CR 14-0599-PRPCSTATE v. WRIGHTMEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Patricia K. Norris, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

8/30/2016   1 CA-MH 16-0005-SPIN RE: RANDY L.MEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Jon W. Thompson, Concur

8/25/2016   1 CA-CR 15-0351STATE v. JOHNSONMEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Patricia K. Norris, Concur

8/25/2016   1 CA-CR 15-0351STATE v. JOHNSONOPINION
 Maurice Portley, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Patricia K. Norris, Concur

 Whether the superior court may consider a defendant’s out-of-state felony convictions in determining whether he or she is a repetitive offender.
8/23/2016   1 CA-CR 15-0049STATE v. ARVALLOMEMORANDUM
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; John C. Gemmill, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

8/23/2016   1 CA-CR 15-0575STATE v. GONZALESMEMORANDUM
 Patricia K. Norris, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

8/18/2016   1 CA-CR 15-0381STATE v. BENNETTMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur; Jon W. Thompson, Concur

8/18/2016   1 CA-CV 15-0206MAASSEN v. STATEMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur; Jon W. Thompson, Concur

8/18/2016   1 CA-CR 15-0565STATE v. DODDMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur; Jon W. Thompson, Concur

8/16/2016   1 CA-CR 15-0503STATE v. BLACKWELLMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Kent E. Cattani, Concur; Donn Kessler, Concur

8/16/2016   1 CA-JV 16-0127ANGELA M. v. SEAN S., E.S.MEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Jon W. Thompson, Concur

8/2/2016   1 CA-CR 14-0563-PRPCSTATE v. HARRISONMEMORANDUM
 Jon W. Thompson, Author; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

7/28/2016   1 CA-CR 15-0519STATE v. FALCONEMEMORANDUM
  1 CA-CR 15-0522STATE v. FALCONE
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Kent E. Cattani, Concur; Donn Kessler, Concur

7/28/2016   1 CA-CR 15-0470STATE v. ZARCOMEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Patricia K. Norris, Concur

7/28/2016   1 CA-CV 15-0464-FCSENTER v. SENTERMEMORANDUM
 Kent E. Cattani, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Donn Kessler, Concur

7/28/2016   1 CA-CR 14-0436-PRPCSTATE v. WARLINGMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie; Kent E. Cattani; Donn Kessler

7/26/2016   1 CA-JV 15-0357MARC S. v. ROBYN P./WILLIAM P.MEMORANDUM
 Donn Kessler, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Kent E. Cattani, Concur

7/26/2016   1 CA-CR 14-0562-PRPCSTATE v. VIDALMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur; Jon W. Thompson, Concur

7/26/2016   1 CA-JV 16-0033DIEGO G. v. DCS, N.G.MEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Patricia K. Norris, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

7/26/2016   1 CA-CR 14-0331-PRPCSTATE v. MARKLANDMEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Jon W. Thompson, Concur

7/21/2016   1 CA-CV 15-0776-FCCORKERY v. LOVEMEMORANDUM
 Patricia K. Norris, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

7/21/2016   1 CA-JV 16-0006HALLIE D. v. DCS, J.D.MEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Patricia K. Norris, Concur

7/21/2016   1 CA-CR 15-0486STATE v. MARTINEZMEMORANDUM
 Donn Kessler, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Kent E. Cattani, Concur

7/21/2016   1 CA-CR 15-0510STATE v. PARKERMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Patricia K. Norris, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

7/21/2016   1 CA-CV 15-0719-FCKROON v. KROONMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Patricia K. Norris, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

7/19/2016   1 CA-JV 15-0384JOSEPHINE L. v. DCS, et al.MEMORANDUM
 Patricia K. Norris, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

7/5/2016   1 CA-JV 15-0399SANDRA T. v. TREVOR A., H.T.MEMORANDUM
 Kent E. Cattani, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Donn Kessler, Concur

7/5/2016   1 CA-CV 15-0480-FCESCAMILLA v. ACUNAMEMORANDUM
 Kent E. Cattani, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Donn Kessler, Concur

7/5/2016   1 CA-CV 14-0657KIMBALL et al. v. PERKINSMEMORANDUM
 Kent E. Cattani, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Donn Kessler, Concur

7/5/2016   1 CA-CR 15-0506STATE v. LARAOPINION
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Kent E. Cattani, Concur; Donn Kessler, Concur

 In a felony shoplifting prosecution under A.R.S. § 13-1805(I), is the existence of two prior shoplifting convictions an element of the charged offense or a sentencing enhancer?
6/30/2016   1 CA-CR 14-0354-PRPCSTATE v. WALTONMEMORANDUM
 Donn Kessler, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Kent E. Cattani, Concur

12345678910...