Search 

Court of Appeals

Division One

Search filter ON - Top 1000 records found    Clear search filter
Judge: Downie, Margaret H.
Search Decisions

12345678910...
12/18/2014   1 CA-IC 14-0029HUGHES v. CARRABBAS/TRAVELERSMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

12/18/2014   1 CA-CV 14-0176FOSTER v. QUARTZSITE et al.MEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Andrew W. Gould, Concur

12/18/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0649MERRILL v. MERRILLMEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Andrew W. Gould, Concur

12/16/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0624ROTH v. MEEKMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

12/16/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0435STATE v. KIRKLANDMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie; Patricia K. Norris; Randall M. Howe

12/11/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0612MULCAIRE v. MONGINI/WALLACEMEMORANDUM
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

12/11/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0319STATE v. COULTEROPINION
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Andrew W. Gould, Concur

 1. Whether the aggravating circumstance that, as a result of a criminal defendant’s conduct, “the victim’s immediate family suffered . . . emotional or financial harm” is unconstitutionally vague.

2. Whether the jury be asked to make separate findings as to the two alternatives for this aggravating circumstance, i.e., asked to make findings addressing (1) emotional harm and (2) financial harm.
12/9/2014   1 CA-JV 14-0186ERIN R. v. DCS, M.R.MEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

12/9/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0742COMMERCE/CRA v. ZINKE et al. MEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

12/9/2014   1 CA-JV 14-0193SHERRI C. v. DCS, T.O.MEMORANDUM
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

12/9/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0422MANS v. LAWSONMEMORANDUM
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

12/4/2014   1 CA-JV 14-0174ALICIA H. v. DCS, C.H.MEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Andrew W. Gould, Concur

12/2/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0429STATE v. YOUNGMEMORANDUM
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

12/2/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0399STATE v. PUTNAMMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

12/2/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0163STATE v. GEESLINMEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Andrew W. Gould, Concur

12/2/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0720JENNIFFER G. v. DCS/CPSMEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Andrew W. Gould, Concur

11/25/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0726ADAMS v. AZ MAXILLOFACIAL et al.MEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

11/25/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0520JACKSON v. JACKSONMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

11/25/2014   1 CA-CV 14-0042BANNER v. MCBANEMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

11/25/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0353STATE v. MORGANMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie; Andrew W. Gould; Samuel A. Thumma

11/20/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0571STATE v. JOHNSONMEMORANDUM
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

11/20/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0380STATE v. CAVANESSMEMORANDUM
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

11/20/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0604STROVINK v. JONESMEMORANDUM
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

11/20/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0491PESETSKY v. PESETSKYMEMORANDUM
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

11/18/2014   1 CA-CV 14-0359MADRID v. AVALON, et al.OPINION
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Andrew W. Gould, Concur

 Whether this court has appellate jurisdiction over a judgment stating “that no further matters remain pending,” Ariz. R. Civ. P. 54(c), even though claims remain pending in the superior court?
11/18/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0485CRAVEN et al. v. HUPPENTHAL et al.OPINION
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

 Whether the superior court properly entered summary judgment against parents of charter school students who allege that Arizona's statutory funding scheme for charter schools violates the equal protection and general and uniform clauses of the Arizona Constitution.
11/13/2014   1 CA-CV 14-0055SHANO v. SHANOMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

11/10/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0355CORNERSTONE v. KOZUBMEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Andrew W. Gould, Concur

11/10/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0826STATE v. BAGDONASMEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Andrew W. Gould, Concur

11/4/2014   1 CA-JV 14-0106CANDRA H. v. DCS, C.H.MEMORANDUM
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

11/4/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0467STATE v. CARRIERMEMORANDUM
 Donn Kessler, Author; Kenton D. Jones, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

10/30/2014   1 CA-JV 14-0120AUTUMN R. v. DCS, P.W.MEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

10/30/2014   1 CA-JV 14-0114JOSEPH F. v. DCS, J.P.MEMORANDUM
  1 CA-JV 14-0133JOSEPH F. v. DCS, J.P.
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

10/30/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0551MCNAMARA et al. v. CITIZENS et al.OPINION
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

 

Whether qualified electors may maintain a private cause of action based on alleged violations of A.R.S. § 16-915.01 (disposal and use of surplus monies held by political committees).   

10/30/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0484MEDRANO et al. v. MARICOPA et al.MEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Andrew W. Gould, Concur

10/28/2014   1 CA-JV 14-0081FRANCES M. v. DCS, et al.MEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Andrew W. Gould, Concur

10/21/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0254STATE v. ZAMORA-OSUNAMEMORANDUM
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

10/21/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0068STATE v. HERRELLMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie; Andrew W. Gould; Samuel A. Thumma

10/21/2014   1 CA-SA 14-0054DARRAH v. HON. MCCLENNEN/MESAOPINION
 Michael J. Brown, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Kent E. Cattani, Special Concurrence

 Whether the Arizona Medical Marijuana Act prohibits the State from prosecuting an authorized medical marijuana user for driving under the influence pursuant to Arizona Revised Statutes section 28-1381(A)(3), which criminalizes driving while there is any prohibited drug or its metabolite in a person's body.
10/21/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0439KERN INVESTORS v. LINKMEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Andrew W. Gould, Concur

10/16/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0221STATE v. COLEMANMEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Andrew W. Gould, Concur

10/14/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0088MOHR v. MURPHY ELEMENTARY ET AL.MEMORANDUM
  1 CA-CV 13-0142MOHR v. MURPHY ELEMENTARY ET AL.
 Michael J. Brown, Author; Kent E. Cattani, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

10/9/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0659BERKLEY, et al. v. KOENIGMEMORANDUM
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

10/9/2014   1 CA-CR 14-0150STATE v. COVENMEMORANDUM
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

10/7/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0478LIM v. GILLIES, et al. MEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

10/7/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0630SNYDER v. BANNER/GOELMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

10/7/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0447KILRAIN v. ADOC, et al. MEMORANDUM
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

9/30/2014   1 CA-CR 12-0207STATE v. DOZIERMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Jon W. Thompson, Concur in part; Dissent in part

9/30/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0370GRANVILLE v. HOWARD OPINION
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Kenton D. Jones, Concur; Donn Kessler, Concur

 What factors should trial courts consider when awarding attorneys’ fees under Rule 77(f) after a trial de novo from an arbitration appeal.
9/30/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0428FISHER v. EDGERTONOPINION
 Donn Kessler, Author; Kenton D. Jones, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

 

Do Ariz. R. Civ. P. 77(f) and A.R.S. § 12-133(I), providing for an award of fees after a trial de novo from a court-ordered arbitration award, permit a court to award fees when a defendant unsuccessfully attempts to shift allocation of fault to another defendant? 


Are the provisions for awards of fees after a trial de novo from court-ordered arbitration unconstitutional under principles of due process, equal protection or by infringing the right to a jury trial?


Constitutionality Decision

A.R.S. § 12-133(I) and Ariz. R. Civ. P. 77(f) do not violate Art. 2, §§ 4, 13, and 23, of the the Arizona Constitution . 

12345678910...