Search 

Court of Appeals

Division One

Search Decisions

Search filter ON - Top 1000 records found    Clear search filter
Judge: Downie, Margaret H.
Search Decisions

12345678910...
10/16/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0221STATE v. COLEMANMEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Andrew W. Gould, Concur

10/14/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0088MOHR v. MURPHY ELEMENTARY ET AL.MEMORANDUM
  1 CA-CV 13-0142MOHR v. MURPHY ELEMENTARY ET AL.
 Michael J. Brown, Author; Kent E. Cattani, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

10/9/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0659BERKLEY, et al. v. KOENIGMEMORANDUM
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

10/9/2014   1 CA-CR 14-0150STATE v. COVENMEMORANDUM
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

10/7/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0478LIM v. GILLIES, et al. MEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

10/7/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0630SNYDER v. BANNER/GOELMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

10/7/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0447KILRAIN v. ADOC, et al. MEMORANDUM
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

9/30/2014   1 CA-CR 12-0207STATE v. DOZIERMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Jon W. Thompson, Concur in part; Dissent in part

9/30/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0370GRANVILLE v. HOWARD OPINION
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Kenton D. Jones, Concur; Donn Kessler, Concur

 What factors should trial courts consider when awarding attorneys’ fees under Rule 77(f) after a trial de novo from an arbitration appeal.
9/30/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0428FISHER v. EDGERTONOPINION
 Donn Kessler, Author; Kenton D. Jones, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

 

Do Ariz. R. Civ. P. 77(f) and A.R.S. § 12-133(I), providing for an award of fees after a trial de novo from a court-ordered arbitration award, permit a court to award fees when a defendant unsuccessfully attempts to shift allocation of fault to another defendant? 


Are the provisions for awards of fees after a trial de novo from court-ordered arbitration unconstitutional under principles of due process, equal protection or by infringing the right to a jury trial?


Constitutionality Decision

A.R.S. § 12-133(I) and Ariz. R. Civ. P. 77(f) do not violate Art. 2, §§ 4, 13, and 23, of the the Arizona Constitution . 

9/25/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0469BEASLEY-RODRIGUEZ v. RODRIGUEZMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

9/25/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0823STATE v. ROBINSONMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

9/25/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0679STATE v. BERMUDEZMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

9/25/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0217STATE v. BRABHAMMEMORANDUM
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

9/25/2014   1 CA-JV 14-0137TIFFANY F. v. DCS, G.F.MEMORANDUM
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

9/23/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0555STATE v. HUMELHANSMEMORANDUM
 Kenton D. Jones, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Donn Kessler, Concur

9/23/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0558BOND v. SAN TAN, et al.MEMORANDUM
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

9/23/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0435BALAZIC v. BALAZICOPINION
 Kent E. Cattani, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

 

Whether unobjected-to deficiencies in registration under Arizona’s version of the Uniform Interstate Family Support Act (“AUIFSA”) deprive Arizona courts of subject matter jurisdiction to enforce a foreign child support judgment.

9/23/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0681STATE v. DEMPSEYMEMORANDUM
 Donn Kessler, Author; Kenton D. Jones, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

9/23/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0252STATE v. GUTIERREZMEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Andrew W. Gould, Concur

9/18/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0234STATE v. THOMASMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie; Andrew W. Gould; Samuel A. Thumma

9/18/2014   1 CA-CR 14-0140STATE v. DAVISMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Kenton D. Jones, Concur; Donn Kessler, Concur

9/18/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0454STATE v. BENSONMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Kenton D. Jones, Concur; Donn Kessler, Concur

9/18/2014   1 CA-SA 14-0132COURTNEY v. HON. FOSTER/COURTNEYOPINION
 Maurice Portley, Author; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

 Can the superior court determine whether Mother is entitled to parenting time under A.R.S. § 25-403(F) and, if so, modify an order of protection issued?
9/18/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0246STATE v. PRASADMEMORANDUM
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

9/18/2014   1 CA-CV 12-0619LEMAD v. MIRAVISTA, et al.MEMORANDUM
 Kent E. Cattani, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

9/18/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0569HOUSE v. ZUBROD et al.MEMORANDUM
 Patricia K. Norris, Author; John C. Gemmill, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

9/16/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0028REYES v. FRANK'S SERVICE OPINION
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Kent E. Cattani, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

 Whether taxable costs under A.R.S. § 12-332(A) include items such as interpreters for deponents, in-state deposition expenses, no-show fees, videotaping expenses, and private mediation costs that the parties agreed to incur.
9/11/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0804STATE v. SPENCEROPINION
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

 Whether suppression of BAC evidence is required when a medical blood draw occurs after the defendant is told she will be arrested if she does not submit to medical treatment.
9/4/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0182KANG v. KANGMEMORANDUM
 Michael J. Brown, Author; Kent E. Cattani, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

9/4/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0707STATE v. TORRESMEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Maurice Portley, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

9/4/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0939STATE v. KRENTIRASMEMORANDUM
 Donn Kessler, Author; Kenton D. Jones, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

9/4/2014   1 CA-JV 13-0325LISA H. v. DCS, et al.MEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

8/28/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0798STATE v. ARMENTAMEMORANDUM
 Kent E. Cattani, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

8/28/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0336NESBITT v. RADISSONMEMORANDUM
 Kent E. Cattani, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

8/26/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0646STATE v. WIESSNERMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

8/21/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0110STATE v. ESTOBARMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur

8/19/2014   1 CA-JV 14-0036MANUEL T. v. DCS, et al.MEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Maurice Portley, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

8/19/2014   1 CA-CR 12-0820STATE v. SETTLE IIMEMORANDUM
 Maurice Portley, Author; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

8/14/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0041STATE v. FRANKMEMORANDUM
 Samuel A. Thumma, Author; Maurice Portley, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

8/5/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0751STATE v. HERNANDEZMEMORANDUM
 Kenton D. Jones, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Donn Kessler, Concur

7/29/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0263STATE v. ROMEROMEMORANDUM
 Diane M. Johnsen, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Patricia K. Norris, Concur

7/29/2014   1 CA-CR 12-0819STATE v. LUAOPINION
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Kent E. Cattani, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

 
Whether “provocation manslaughter” under A.R.S. § 13-1103(A)(2) is a lesser included offense of second degree murder.
7/29/2014   1 CA-CR 12-0819STATE v. LUAMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Kent E. Cattani, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

7/24/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0376STATE v. SUTTONMEMORANDUM
 Kent E. Cattani, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

7/24/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0344STATE v. WIGGINSMEMORANDUM
 Patricia K. Norris, Author; Margaret H. Downie, Concur; Diane M. Johnsen, Concur

7/17/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0881STATE v. GOMEZMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Kenton D. Jones, Concur; Donn Kessler, Concur

7/17/2014   1 CA-CR 13-0177STATE v. MORENOMEMORANDUM
 Margaret H. Downie, Author; Kent E. Cattani, Concur; Michael J. Brown, Concur

7/15/2014   1 CA-CV 13-0424SULLIVAN v. HOMES et al.MEMORANDUM
 Donn Kessler, Author; Kenton D. Jones, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

7/15/2014   1 CA-CR 12-0643STATE v. VARELAMEMORANDUM
 Donn Kessler, Author; Kenton D. Jones, Concur; Margaret H. Downie, Concur

12345678910...