Search 

Judicial Performance Review

Who Judges the Judges? You Do!

NEWS and MEETINGS

 

 

No matching records found.

 

 

Judicial Decisions

This search utility below is available for decisions filed with the Arizona Supreme Court and Court of Appeals, Division I.

Click here to search Court of Appeals, Division II.
Search filter ON - Top 1000 records found    Clear search filter
Judge: Timmer, Ann A. Scott
Search Decisions

12345678910...
8/17/2017   CV-16-0301-SASTATE ex rel BRNOVICH v CITY OF TUCSON/DEWITOPINION
  John Pelander, Author; Scott Bales, Concur; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; Ann A. Scott Timmer, Concur; Clint Bolick, Concur in part; Andrew W. Gould, Concur in part; John R. Lopez, IV, Concur in part

 

PLEASE NOTE: On August 17, 2017, an Order was filed correcting the following sentences:

¶ 53, shall be amended by changing the word “quoting” to “citing” immediately before “Duncan v. Louisiana,” as shown below.


Constitutionality Decision

Upholding relevant portions of S.B. 1487, codified in A.R.S. § 41-194.01, under article 6, section 5(6) of the Arizona Constitution, and rejecting challenges that S.B. 1487 violates the separation of powers and this Court’s rule-making authority under article 3 and article 6, sections 1, 5(5), respectively, of the Arizona Constitution.

 

Upholding A.R.S. §§ 12-943, 12-945(B), and 13-3108(F) against challenge that a conflicting city ordinance supersedes and controls over the statutes under article 13, section 2 of the Arizona Constitution.


8/17/2017   CV-16-0301-SASTATE ex rel BRNOVICH v CITY OF TUCSON/DEWITOPINION
  John Pelander, Author; Scott Bales, Concur; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; Ann A. Scott Timmer, Concur; Clint Bolick, Concur in part; Andrew W. Gould, Concur in part; John R. Lopez, IV, Concur

 

Amended by Order on August 17, 2017

8/15/2017   CR-16-0327-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v MARK HASKIE, JR. OPINION
 Robert M. Brutinel, Author; Scott Bales, Concur; John Pelander, Concur; Ann A. Scott Timmer, Concur; Clint Bolick, Concur; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur

8/10/2017   CV-16-0107-PRPAWN 1ST LLC v CITY OF PHOENIX ET AL/JACHIMEKOPINION
 John R. Lopez, IV, Author; Scott Bales, Concur; John Pelander, Concur; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; Ann A. Scott Timmer, Concur; Clint Bolick, Concur; Andrew W. Gould, Concur

8/9/2017   CV-16-0156-PRSIRRAH ENTERPRISES LLC v WAYNE WUNDERLICH et uxOPINION
 Ann A. Scott Timmer, Author; Scott Bales, Concur; John Pelander, Concur; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; Clint Bolick, Concur; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; John R. Lopez, IV, Concur

8/3/2017   CV-16-0217-PRDAVID STAMBAUGH v. MARK KILLIAN et alOPINION
 Robert M. Brutinel, Author; Scott Bales, Concur; John Pelander, Concur; Ann A. Scott Timmer, Concur; Clint Bolick, Special Concurrence; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; Michael D. Peterson, Concur

 

 

8/2/2017   CV-16-0314-SACHAMBER OF COMMERCE ET AL v HON. KILEY/STATE ET ALOPINION
 Ann A. Scott Timmer, Author; Scott Bales, Concur; John Pelander, Concur; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; Clint Bolick, Concur; Andrew W. Gould, Concur; John R. Lopez, IV, Concur

 Constitutionality Decision
Upholding Proposition 206, “The Fair Wages and Healthy Families Act,” codified at A.R.S. §§ 23–363
and 23–371 to –381, from challenges under the Arizona Constitution’s Revenue Source Rule,
Separate Amendment Rule, and Single Subject Rule.
7/21/2017   CV-16-0260-PRJ HAMBLEN ET UX v HON. HATCH/WINSLOW MEMORIALOPINION
  John Pelander, Author; Scott Bales, Concur; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; Ann A. Scott Timmer, Concur; Clint Bolick, Concur; John R. Lopez, IV, Concur; Charles W. Gurtler, Concur

7/13/2017   CV-16-0136-PRMICHAEL SOTO et al v ANTHONY M SACCO et alOPINION
 John R. Lopez, IV, Author; Scott Bales, Concur; John Pelander, Concur; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; Ann A. Scott Timmer, Concur; Clint Bolick, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur

7/7/2017   CR-16-0264-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v HON. HEGYI/RASMUSSENOPINION
 Andrew W. Gould, Author; Scott Bales, Concur; John Pelander, Concur; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; Ann A. Scott Timmer, Concur; Clint Bolick, Concur; John R. Lopez, IV, Concur

12345678910...