Opinions

Search Opinions

Search filter ON - 34 records found    Clear search filter
Date Range: 1/1/2007 to 12/31/2007
Court: Arizona Supreme Court 		Search Decisions
12/21/2007   CR-07-0127-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v GARY EDWARD COXOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
12/3/2007   CR-06-0435-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v JACOB PRICEOPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur
12/3/2007   CV-06-0338-PRSTATE FARM v PREMIER MANUFACTURED SYSTEMSOPINION
 Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
Constitutionality Decision
Holding A.R.S. § 12-2506 (joint and several liability abolished) constitutional under Ariz. Const. art. 18, § 6 (recovery of damages for injuries).
12/3/2007   CV-07-0019-PRJANA WALDREN et al v GEORGE WALDRENOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
12/3/2007   CV-07-0154-PRPICASO v TUCSON UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICTOPINION
 Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
11/30/2007   WC-07-0002-IRIN RE IN RE THE GENERAL ADJUDICATION OF ALL RIGHTSOPINION
 Michael D. Ryan, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur
11/1/2007   CV-07-0114-CQMARIAN B FARRIS v ADVANTAGE CAPITAL CORPOPINION
 Michael D. Ryan, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
8/9/2007   CR-04-0361-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v JUAN VELAZQUEZOPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur
8/9/2007   CV-07-0018-PRKROMKO et al v ARIZONA BOARD OF REGENTS/STATEOPINION
 Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Joseph W Howard, Concur
7/25/2007   CR-06-0385-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v RODNEY JOSEPH GANTOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Dissent; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur in the Dissent
7/12/2007   CR-06-0143-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v DARREL PETER PANDELIOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; Patricia K Norris, Concur
Constitutionality Decision
Holding A.R.S. § 13-751(F)(2) (previous conviction as aggravating factor) constitutional under U.S. Const. amend. 6 (rights of accused in criminal prosecutions). Holding A.R.S. § 13-751(F)(6) (cruelty aggravator) constitutional under U.S. Const. amends. 5, 14 (due process). Holding A.R.S. § 13-703 (repetitive offenders; sentencing) constitutional on severability grounds.
7/9/2007   CR-05-0005-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v WENDI ELIZABETH ANDRIANOOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
Constitutionality Decision
Holding A.R.S. § 13-704(A) (lethal injection statute) constitutional under U.S. Const. amend. 8 (cruel and unusual punishment).
6/29/2007   CR-04-0343-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v RUBEN GARZAOPINION
 Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
Constitutionality Decision
Holding A.R.S. § 13-703.01(P) (renumbered as § 13-752; the trier of fact shall make factual determinations required to impose death in the aggravation phase) constitutional under U.S. Const. amend. 6 (rights of accused in criminal prosecutions). Holding A.R.S. § 13-703(E), (H) (capital sentencing aggravation and mitigation scheme) constitutional under U.S. Const. amend. 8 (cruel and unusual punishment).
6/29/2007   CV-06-0377-PRNORTHWEST FIRE DISTRICT v US HOME OF AZ et alOPINION
 Michael D. Ryan, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
6/28/2007   CV-07-0066-SAHON. MICHAEL K CARROLL v COMM ON JUDICIAL CONDUCTOPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur
6/18/2007   CR-05-0267-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v CORY DEONN MORRISOPINION
 Ruth V. McGregor, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
6/13/2007   CR-05-0162-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v EUGENE ROBERT TUCKEROPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Jon W Thompson, Concur
6/8/2007   CV-06-0358-PRKLAY KOHL SR/GEORGIA KOHL v CITY OF PHOENIXOPINION
 Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
5/31/2007   CR-04-0208-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v JOE CLARENCE SMITHOPINION
 Michael D. Ryan, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; Maurice Portley, Concur
5/30/2007   CR-06-0459-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v KAREN MARIE HANSENOPINION
 Ruth V. McGregor, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
5/24/2007   JC-06-0002In the Matter of HON. JACQUELINE B McVAYOPINION
 Michael D. Ryan, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
5/8/2007   CR-06-0374-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v MAURICIO MORALESOPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur
4/25/2007   CV-06-0312-PRSTANLEY GRIFFIS v PINAL COUNTY/PHOENIX NEWSOPINION
 Ruth V. McGregor, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
3/20/2007   CV-06-0181-PRWILLIAM ROUBOS et al v HON. LESLIE MILLER/TUCSONOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
3/20/2007   CV-06-0303-PRSTATE ex rel THOMAS v HON. RAYES/REYNAGAOPINION
 Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
3/14/2007   CV-06-0333-AP/ELFLEISCHMAN et al v PROTECT OUR CITY/PANIAGUA et alOPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur
2/26/2007   CV-06-0275-PRDEER VALLEY v HON. ROBERT HOUSER/PAMELA McDONALDOPINION
 Ruth V. McGregor, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
2/21/2007   SB-06-0121-DIn the Matter of CARLY VAN DOXOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; Lawrence F Winthrop, Concur
2/9/2007   CV-06-0320-PRDAVID GARCIA v HON. CHRISTOPHER BROWNING/STATEOPINION
 Michael D. Ryan, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
1/23/2007   CV-06-0076-PRGEORGE WINN v PLAZA HEALTHCARE et alOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
1/22/2007   CV-06-0100-PRSUSAN GIPSON v LARRY KASEY/JANE DOE KASEYOPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur
1/18/2007   CR-06-0205-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v JOHN DAVID CRAWFORDOPINION
 Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
1/12/2007   CV-06-0277-AP/ELAZ TOGETHER et al v JAN BREWER/PROTECT MARRIAGE AZOPINION
 Ruth V. McGregor, Author; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur
1/10/2007   CV-06-0280-SAHAYWOOD SECURITIES v HONS EHRLICH/BARKER et alOPINION
 Michael D. Ryan, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur