Opinions

Search Opinions

Search filter ON - 37 records found    Clear search filter
Date Range: 1/1/2008 to 12/31/2008
Court: Arizona Supreme Court 		Search Decisions
11/18/2008   CV-08-0275-AP/ELTRANSPORTATION INFRASTRUCTURE et al v BREWER et alOPINION
 Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
11/3/2008   CR-07-0412-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v GARY DOUGLAS PEEKOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
11/3/2008   CV-08-0057-PR1800 OCOTILLO LLC v THE WLB GROUP INCOPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur
10/30/2008   CR-08-0033-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v CHARLES EUGENE SMITHOPINION
 Michael D. Ryan, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
10/30/2008   CR-08-0051-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v MARCEL BARRY THOMASOPINION
 Ruth V. McGregor, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
10/9/2008   CR-07-0429-PRSTATE v HUBERT AUGUST STUMMER/DENNIS ALLEN LUMMOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
Constitutionality Decision
Evaluating constitutionality of A.R.S. § 13-1422 (limiting hours of operation of adult oriented businesses) under U.S. Const. amend. 1 (free speech clause) and remanding to the trial court for further proceedings in which both parties could present evidence applicable to the test for constitutionality detailed in the courts opinion.
9/25/2008   CV-08-0269-AP/ELWILHELM et al v BREWER et al/HOMEOWNERS BILLOPINION
 Michael D. Ryan, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
8/22/2008   CR-05-0149-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v JAMES GRANVIL WALLACEOPINION
 Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Donn Kessler, Concur
8/22/2008   CV-08-0199-AP/ELKEITH A BEE v DAY et al/ KENTOPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur
8/19/2008   CV-07-0416-PRTHE LOFTS AT FILLMORE v RELIANCE COMMERCIALOPINION
 Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
8/19/2008   CV-08-0026-PRSTEVEN H./TAMMY H. v ADES/MATTHEW H./SAVANNAH H.OPINION
 Michael D. Ryan, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
8/19/2008   CV-08-0208-AP/ELROYCE JENKINS v HALE et alOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; W. Scott Bales, Concur; Patrick Irvine, Concur
8/8/2008   CR-06-0295-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v PHILLIP ALAN BOCHARSKIOPINION
 Ruth V. McGregor, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
8/4/2008   CV-07-0300-PRGILBERT PROSECUTOR v HON. DOWNIE/MATYKIEWICZOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur in part; Ruth V. McGregor, Dissent; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
7/29/2008   CR-06-0443-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v SHAD DANIEL ARMSTRONGOPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Patricia A Orozco, Concur
Constitutionality Decision
Holding A.R.S. § 13-703.01(R) (victim impact statements) constitutional under Ariz. Const. art. 2, § 2.1 (victim's bill of rights).
7/29/2008   CR-08-0001-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v ENIS JOHN CHERAMIE IIIOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
7/28/2008   CR-04-0098-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v DAVID LAMAR ANTHONYOPINION
 Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
7/25/2008   CR-05-0507-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v CODY JAMES MARTINEZOPINION
 Michael D. Ryan, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
7/25/2008   CV-07-0402-PRM CULLEN/J CORONADO v AUTO OWNERSOPINION
 Ruth V. McGregor, Author; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Dissent in part; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
7/25/2008   CV-07-0412-PRFIRST AMERICAN TITLE v ACTION ACQUISITIONS et alOPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur
7/11/2008   CV-08-0195-AP/ELTHOMAS HANEY v TOM RICE et alMEMORANDUM
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
6/17/2008   CR-07-0319-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v ANN MAVINEE LEENHOUTSOPINION
 Ruth V. McGregor, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
6/16/2008   CR-05-0174-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v STEVE ALAN BOGGSOPINION
 Ruth V. McGregor, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
5/8/2008   CV-07-0349-PRHAL OWENS v ME SCHEPP LPOPINION
 Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
4/25/2008   CV-07-0293-PRJAMES L LEE et al v STATE OF ARIZONAOPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Dissent; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur in the Dissent
4/24/2008   CV-07-0265-PRPHOENIX CITY PROSECUTOR v HON. YBARRA/LANDERSOPINION
 Michael D. Ryan, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
4/21/2008   CR-05-0163-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v JOHN MONTENEGRO CRUZOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
4/9/2008   CR-05-0174-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v STEVE ALAN BOGGSOPINION
 Ruth V. McGregor, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
4/9/2008   CV-07-0288-PRADOR v ACTION MARINE/RANDALL et alOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Dissent; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur in the Dissent
2/21/2008   CV-07-0222-PRSARAH M HEATH v HON. WILLIAM T KIGER/STATEOPINION
 Ruth V. McGregor, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
2/14/2008   CR-05-0461-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v JAMES CORNELL HARRODOPINION
 Michael D. Ryan, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; John C Gemmill, Concur
2/14/2008   CR-05-0508-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v FRANK DALE MCCRAYOPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur
2/14/2008   CV-07-0207-PRSALT RIVER PROJECT v MILLER PARK LLC et alOPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur
2/14/2008   CV-07-0251-PRDALE JOSEPH FUSHEK v STATE OF ARIZONAOPINION
 Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur
2/14/2008   CV-07-0280-PREMPLOYERS MUTUAL CASUALTY CO v DGG & CAR INC et alOPINION
 Michael D. Ryan, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
1/10/2008   CV-07-0057-PRJEAN CUNDIFF v STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTO INSURANCEOPINION
 Ruth V. McGregor, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur
1/10/2008   CV-07-0127-PRD JERE' WEBB v VICTORIA GITTLEN et alOPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Ruth V. McGregor, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur