Opinions

Search Opinions

Search filter ON - 36 records found    Clear search filter
Date Range: 1/1/2011 to 12/31/2011
Court: Arizona Supreme Court 		Search Decisions
12/21/2011   CR-09-0253-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v JAHMARI ALI MANUELOPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur; Robert M Brutinel, Concur
12/21/2011   CV-11-0028-PRCLIFFORD J OCHSER v GERARD FUNK/ANTHONY CRUZOPINION
 A. John Pelander, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; Robert M Brutinel, Concur
12/20/2011   CR-11-0040-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v DOUGLAS LEE EDDINGTONOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur; Robert M Brutinel, Concur
11/30/2011   CV-10-0300-PRESTATE OF BRADEN/GABALDON v STATE et alOPINION
 Robert M Brutinel, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Dissent; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur in the Dissent
11/23/2011   CV-10-0362MARTIN RIVERA-LONGORIA v HON. SLAYTON/STATE/ROZEMAOPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur; Robert M Brutinel, Concur
11/18/2011   CV-11-0091-CQJULIA VASQUEZ v SAXON MORTGAGE INC et alOPINION
 Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur; Robert M Brutinel, Concur
11/14/2011   CV-11-0264FRANKLIN BRUCE ROSS v KEN BENNETT et alOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur; Robert M Brutinel, Concur
8/4/2011   JC-11-0001In the Matter of HONORABLE THEODORE ABRAMSOPINION
 A. John Pelander, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; Robert M Brutinel, Concur
7/13/2011   CR-09-0095-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v SCOTT ALAN LEHROPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur; Robert M Brutinel, Concur; Patricia A Orozco, Concur
7/8/2011   CV-10-0405-SAADAMS/PEARCE v COMMISSION ON APPELLATE COURT et alOPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Robert M Brutinel, Dissent in part; A. John Pelander, Concur in the Dissent; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur; Robert M Brutinel, Concur in part; A. John Pelander, Concur in part
7/1/2011   CR-90-0356-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v JAMES LYNN STYERSOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Dissent; W. Scott Bales, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur; Robert M Brutinel, Concur
7/1/2011   CV-10-0324-PRAMERICAN ASPHALT v CMX LLC/CMX GROUP INCOPINION
 Robert M Brutinel, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur
7/1/2011   CV-11-0188MARSHALL HOME v ROTHSCHILD/RANDOLPH et alOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Robert M Brutinel, Author
6/30/2011   CV-11-0006ALFRED ALBANO et al v SHEA HOMES/J F SHEA CO INCOPINION
 A. John Pelander, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; Robert M Brutinel, Concur
6/29/2011   CV-10-0397-PRSUE LYNN CRAIG v ROGER THOMAS CRAIGOPINION
 Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur; Robert M Brutinel, Concur
6/10/2011   CR-10-0309-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v MICHAEL QUINCY HUMMONSOPINION
 Robert M Brutinel, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur
5/19/2011   CR-10-0315-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v LAQUINN ANTHONY FISHEROPINION
 Robert M Brutinel, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur
5/12/2011   CR-10-0306-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v WESTOPINION
 A. John Pelander, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; Robert M Brutinel, Concur
5/12/2011   CV-10-0339-PRDESERT MOUNTAIN PROP v LIBERTY MUTUAL FIRE INSOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur; Robert M Brutinel, Concur
5/6/2011   CR-08-0025-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v CLARENCE WAYNE DIXONOPINION
 Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur; Robert M Brutinel, Concur
5/6/2011   CR-09-0019-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v WAYNE BENOIT PRINCEOPINION
 A. John Pelander, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; Robert M Brutinel, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur
Constitutionality Decision
Holding A.R.S. § 13-752(K) (providing for the impaneling of a new jury if the former jury cannot reach a verdict during the first penalty phase) constitutional under Ariz. Const. art. 2 § 25 (ex post facto clause), Ariz. Const. art. 2 § 4 (due process clause), U.S. Const. art. 1 § 10 (ex post facto clause), US Const. amends. 5, 14 (due process clause). Holding A.R.S. § 13-751(F)(6) ("especially heinous" aggravating factor) constitutional under Ariz. Const. art. 2 § 4 (due process clause), U.S. Const. amends. 5, 14 (due process clause).
4/29/2011   CV-10-0327-PRMOREHART/DUFFY v HON. BARTON/STATE/MILLEROPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur; Robert M Brutinel, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur
4/21/2011   CV-10-0285-PRJESUS GUTIERREZ v ICA/MASTERSON et alOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur; Robert M Brutinel, Concur
4/8/2011   CR-09-0133-APSTATE OF ARIZONA v DONALD DAVID DELAHANTYOPINION
 Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur; Robert M Brutinel, Concur
4/7/2011   CV-10-0196-PRLEVERAGED LAND CO et al v MICHAEL W HODGES et alOPINION
 Robert M Brutinel, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur
4/5/2011   CV-10-0230-PRAMY YOUNG v KENNETH L BECK et uxOPINION
 A. John Pelander, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur
3/24/2011   CV-10-0292-PRLETTIE PRESTON et al v KINDRED HOSPITALS et alOPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur; Robert M Brutinel, Concur
3/3/2011   CV-10-0218-PRCITY OF PEORIA/PHOENIX v BRINKS HOME SECURITYOPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur; Robert M Brutinel, Concur
3/1/2011   CR-10-0154-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL REGENOLDOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; A. John Pelander, Dissent; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur
2/16/2011   CR-10-0242-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v LOUIE THOMAS MACHADOOPINION
 Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur
1/26/2011   CR-10-0017-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v CESAR MONTESOPINION
 A. John Pelander, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur
Constitutionality Decision
Holding that the enactment of SB 1449 (providing for the retroactive application of SB 1145, a 2006 law concerning the defense of justification in criminal cases) was a constitutional exercise of legislative authority and not violative of Ariz. Const. art. 3 (separation of powers), U.S. Const. arts. 1-3. (separation of powers).
1/21/2011   CV-10-0189-PRPLANNING GROUP et al v LAKE MATHEWS MINERAL et alOPINION
 Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur
1/20/2011   CV-10-0026-PRLUIS BALLESTEROS et al v AMERICAN STANDARD et alOPINION
 Rebecca White Berch, Author; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur; Peter B Swann, Concur
1/18/2011   CV-10-0172-PRESTATE OF MADDISON DESELA v PRESCOTT UNIFIED et alOPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur; Michael D. Ryan, Concur
1/13/2011   CR-10-0211-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v TROY JASON LEWISOPINION
 Andrew D. Hurwitz, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; W. Scott Bales, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur
1/10/2011   CV-10-0092-PRIN RE NICKOLAS S.OPINION
 W. Scott Bales, Author; Rebecca White Berch, Concur; Andrew D. Hurwitz, Concur; A. John Pelander, Concur; Joseph W Howard, Concur; A. John Pelander, Special Concurrence