FAQ

Register       Login

YOUR HELP NEEDED: If you find a cross-reference that does not match the rule or subsection it refers to or any apparent clerical errors, please let us know by sending a precise description to [email protected].




Current Arizona Rules on Westlaw

Amendments from Recent Rule Agendas

Rule Amendments (2006 to present) 

 

Proposed Local Rules
                


Welcome!

This website allows you to electronically file and monitor court rule petitions and comments and to view existing rules of court, recent amendments of those rules, and pending rule petitions and comments. Any visitor to this site may view posts on this website, but to post a petition or comment you must register and log in. To view instructions on how to register and how to file a petition or comment, please visit our Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) page. 

PLEASE READ - CONTACT INFORMATION: 

PLEASE MAKE SURE THAT YOU SUBMIT ALL YOUR CONTACT INFORMATION WHEN SUBMITTING A RULE PETITION OR COMMENT.  OTHERWISE, YOUR SUBMISSION MAY BE REJECTED AND WE WILL BE UNABLE TO ADVISE YOU AS TO WHY. 

     
PrevPrev Go to previous topic
NextNext Go to next topic
Last Post 01 May 2019 04:22 PM by  Joseph Domanico
R-18-0035 Petition to Amend Rule 15.3(a) of the Rules of Criminal Procedure
 2 Replies
Sort:
Topic is locked
Author Messages
Diana Cooney
New Member
Posts:22 New Member

--
18 Oct 2018 09:17 AM
    Elizabeth Ortiz, Bar No. 012838
    Executive Director
    Arizona Prosecuting Attorneys’ Advisory Council
    1951 West Camelback Road, Suite 202
    Phoenix, AZ 85015-3407
    (602) 542-7222
    [email protected]

    On behalf of the Arizona Prosecuting Attorneys' Advisory Council ("APAAC"), this Petition is filed in the Matter of Petition to Amend Rule 15.3(a) of the Rules of Criminal Procedure, with expedited consideration requested.

    Would revert language in Criminal Rule 15.3(a) from "victim" to "those excluded by Rule 39(b)" to allow prosecutors to seek depositions of crime victims who are unavailable to testify at trial.

    FILED: October 18, 2018

    COMMENTS due: May 1, 2019

    REPLY due: June 3, 2019

    ORDERED: Petition to Amend Rule 15.3(a) of the Rules of Criminal Procedure = ADOPTED on a permanent basis.
    Attachments
    Richard Weiss
    New Member
    Posts:1 New Member

    --
    30 Apr 2019 11:55 AM
    Rules Committee
    R15.3 ARCP
    To whom It may concern:
    I would like to comment that the proposed amendment to Rule 15.3 Arizona Rules of Criminal Procedure which was adopted on an expedited basis on October 24, 2018 should not be adopted.
    I believe when this rule was restyled it did not make any substantive change to the intent of Rule 15.3. Rather it appears the amendment was to clarify that persons described by "Rule 39(b)" were victims. Consequently making such change did not change the purpose of the rule.
    As a retired judge and a member of COVIC, I feel compelled to comment that the proposed change infringes upon the victim's right to justice and due process. In particular, "to be free from intimidation, harassment or abuse, throughout the criminal justice process." Further, to some extent "to refuse an interview, deposition ... request by the defendant.." . Article 24 Section 2.1 (A) 1. and 5 of the Arizona Constitution.
    This amendment appears to allow the State to depose a victim as a sword to develop evidence against a defendant. In doing so upon the State Notice of Deposition of a Victim the victim would be unable to refuse an interview and in this case, deposition, in which the defendant, generally through counsel would have a right to cross-examine the victim. This would infringe upon the victim's right to privacy - self-determination as to the extent of participation the victim wishes to have in a criminal justice process. In fact, there may be situations, particularly in refusal to prosecute cases that a victim makes a choice to not participate in the criminal justice system, perhaps based on safety concerns as the victim evaluates the circumstances of any alleged criminal event. The criminal justice system should not provide the state a sword to challenge the victim's self determination of any action they may wish to take.
    Typically, victim's right(s) provisions are shields to be invoked by a victim based upon their individual assessment of a criminal offense. This proposed rule evaporates the victim's individual right to determine his or her participation in the criminal justice system by forcing them to be deposed by the State and then be subject to cross-examination by a defendant possibly against their will.
    It is acknowledged that there are circumstances in which a victim may choose to be deposed to preserve evidence. Such decisions should be based upon unavailability concerns of a victim, with or without the assistance of the state.
    In conclusion, I urge that this expedited amendment be rejected and the restyled version of Rule 15.3 ARCP remain in place.
    Thank you for your consideration.
    Richard Weiss
    Retired Superior Court Judge
    COVIC Member
    609 Country Club Dr.
    Kingman, Arizona 86401
    [email protected]
    ABN: 007013
    Joseph Domanico
    New Member
    Posts:26 New Member

    --
    01 May 2019 04:22 PM
    WILLIAM G. MONTGOMERY
    MARICOPA COUNTY ATTORNEY
    (FIRM STATE BAR NO. 00032000)

    MICHAEL R. MCVEY
    CHIEF DEPUTY (ACTING)
    301 WEST JEFFERSON STREET, SUITE 800
    PHOENIX, ARIZONA 85003
    TELEPHONE: (602) 506-3800
    (STATE BAR NUMBER 006926)
    [email protected]

    MARICOPA COUNTY ATTORNEY’S RESPONSE TO PETITION TO AMEND RULE 15.3(a), ARIZONA RULES OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE
    Attachments
    Topic is locked