2012


Public Decisions Summary

 

  Removals: (0) 

Case Number Judge(s) Complainant(s) Disposition(s)

 

  Suspensions: (0) 

Case Number Judge(s) Complainant(s) Disposition(s)

 

  Censures: (1) 

Case Number Judge(s) Complainant(s) Disposition(s)
2012-177
 Carmine Cornelio Andrea Watters Formal Sanction
(Censured)

 

  Reprimands: (23) 

Case Number Judge(s) Complainant(s) Disposition(s)
2012-315
 Gary Goetteman Judge Peter Cahill Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-308
 Anne Fisher Segal Ivo Ortiz Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-300
 Sheila A. Madden Self-report Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-282
 Fred L. Peterson Self-report Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-275
 Melanie DeForest C. Steven McMurry Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-266
 Melanie DeForest Judicial Conduct Commission Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-265
 Crane McClennen Eleanor L. Miller Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-263
 Robert L. Gottsfield John Catapano Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-261
 Butch L. Gunnels Anonymous
Hon. Donna Grimsley		 Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-255
 John Basteen Steven Tucker Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-234
 Edward W. Bassett Kim (Kimmie) Baker Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-218
 Keith Barth Judicial Conduct Commission Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-197
 Marie Martinez Jeffery Mehrens Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-179
 Marie Martinez Keith Ambrose Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-178
 Jeanette Umphress Self-report Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-176
 Joseph Lodge Mark R. Moran Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-135
 Lawrence C. King Mike Palmer Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-128
 Anne Fisher Segal Self-report Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-118
 Keith Frankel
Ronald I. Karp		 Myra Harris Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-104
 Clancy L. Jayne Anonymous Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-051
 Phillip Woolbright Gerald Williams Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-029
 Michael A. Lester David Osterfeld Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)
2012-012
 Mark Chiles Laurie Herman Informal Sanction
(Public reprimand)

 

  Dismissals with comments: (32) 

Case Number Disposition(s)
2012-360
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-359
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-353
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-352
 Dismissal with Comments
(Warning)
2012-349
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-336
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-316
 Dismissal with Comments
(Warning)
2012-312
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-301
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-277
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-273
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-254
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-223
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-214
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-204
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-180
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-174
 Dismissal with Comments
(Warning)
2012-156
 Dismissal with Comments
(Warning)
2012-136
 Dismissal with Comments
(Warning)
2012-130
 Dismissal with Comments
(Warning)
2012-110
 Dismissal with Comments
(Warning)
2012-108
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-094
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-091
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-084
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-072
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-056
 Dismissal with Comments
(Warning)
2012-052
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-025
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-015
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-014
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)
2012-004
 Dismissal with Comments
(Advisory letter)

 

  Dismissals: (305) 

Case Number Disposition(s)
2012-361
 Dismissal
2012-358
 Dismissal
2012-357
 Dismissal
2012-356
 Dismissal
2012-355
 Dismissal
2012-354
 Dismissal
2012-351
 Dismissal
2012-350
 Dismissal
2012-348
 Dismissal
2012-347
 Dismissal
2012-346
 Dismissal
2012-345
 Dismissal
2012-344
 Dismissal
2012-343
 Dismissal
2012-342
 Dismissal
2012-341
 Dismissal
2012-340
 Dismissal
2012-339
 Dismissal
2012-338
 Dismissal
2012-337
 Dismissal
2012-335
 Dismissal
2012-334
 Dismissal
2012-333
 Dismissal
2012-332
 Dismissal
2012-331
 Dismissal
2012-330
 Dismissal
2012-329
 Dismissal
2012-328
 Dismissal
2012-327
 Dismissal
2012-326
 Dismissal
2012-325
 Dismissal
2012-324
 Dismissal
2012-323
 Dismissal
2012-322
 Dismissal
2012-321
 Dismissal
2012-320
 Dismissal
2012-319
 Dismissal
2012-318
 Dismissal
2012-317
 Dismissal
2012-314
 Dismissal
2012-313
 Dismissal
2012-311
 Dismissal
2012-310
 Dismissal
2012-309
 Dismissal
2012-307
 Dismissal
2012-306
 Dismissal
2012-305
 Dismissal
2012-304
 Dismissal
2012-303
 Dismissal
2012-302
 Dismissal
2012-299
 Dismissal
2012-298
 Dismissal
2012-297
 Dismissal
2012-296
 Dismissal
2012-295
 Dismissal
2012-294
 Dismissal
2012-293
 Dismissal
2012-292
 Dismissal
2012-291
 Dismissal
2012-290
 Dismissal
2012-289
 Dismissal
2012-288
 Dismissal
2012-287
 Dismissal
2012-286
 Dismissal
2012-285
 Dismissal
2012-284
 Dismissal
2012-283
 Dismissal
2012-281
 Dismissal
2012-280
 Dismissal
2012-279
 Dismissal
2012-278
 Dismissal
2012-276
 Dismissal
2012-274
 Dismissal
2012-272
 Dismissal
2012-271
 Dismissal
2012-270
 Dismissal
2012-269
 Dismissal
2012-268
 Dismissal
2012-267
 Dismissal
2012-264
 Dismissal
2012-262
 Dismissal
2012-260
 Dismissal
2012-259
 Dismissal
2012-258
 Dismissal
2012-257
 Dismissal
2012-256
 Dismissal
2012-253
 Dismissal
2012-252
 Dismissal
2012-251
 Dismissal
2012-250
 Dismissal
2012-249
 Dismissal
2012-248
 Dismissal
2012-247
 Dismissal
2012-246
 Dismissal
2012-245
 Dismissal
2012-244
 Dismissal
2012-243
 Dismissal
2012-242
 Dismissal
2012-241
 Dismissal
2012-240
 Dismissal
2012-239
 Dismissal
2012-238
 Dismissal
2012-237
 Dismissal
2012-236
 Dismissal
2012-235
 Dismissal
2012-233
 Dismissal
2012-232
 Dismissal
2012-231
 Dismissal
2012-230
 Dismissal
2012-229
 Dismissal
2012-228
 Dismissal
2012-227
 Dismissal
2012-226
 Dismissal
2012-225
 Dismissal
2012-224
 Dismissal
2012-222
 Dismissal
2012-221
 Dismissal
2012-220
 Dismissal
2012-219
 Dismissal
2012-217
 Dismissal
2012-216
 Dismissal
2012-215
 Dismissal
2012-213
 Dismissal
2012-212
 Dismissal
2012-211
 Dismissal
2012-210
 Dismissal
2012-209
 Dismissal
2012-208
 Dismissal
2012-207
 Dismissal
2012-206
 Dismissal
2012-205
 Dismissal
2012-203
 Dismissal
2012-202
 Dismissal
2012-201
 Dismissal
2012-200
 Dismissal
2012-199
 Dismissal
2012-198
 Dismissal
2012-196
 Dismissal
2012-195
 Dismissal
2012-194
 Dismissal
2012-193
 Dismissal
2012-192
 Dismissal
2012-191
 Dismissal
2012-190
 Dismissal
2012-189
 Dismissal
2012-188
 Dismissal
2012-187
 Dismissal
2012-186
 Dismissal
2012-185
 Dismissal
2012-184
 Dismissal
2012-183
 Dismissal
2012-182
 Dismissal
2012-181
 Dismissal
2012-175
 Dismissal
2012-173
 Dismissal
2012-172
 Dismissal
2012-171
 Dismissal
2012-170
 Dismissal
2012-169
 Dismissal
2012-168
 Dismissal
2012-167
 Dismissal
2012-166
 Dismissal
2012-165
 Dismissal
2012-164
 Dismissal
2012-163
 Dismissal
2012-162
 Dismissal
2012-161
 Dismissal
2012-160
 Dismissal
2012-159
 Dismissal
2012-158
 Dismissal
2012-157
 Dismissal
2012-155
 Dismissal
2012-154
 Dismissal
2012-153
 Dismissal
2012-152
 Dismissal
2012-151
 Dismissal
2012-150
 Dismissal
2012-149
 Dismissal
2012-148
 Dismissal
2012-147
 Dismissal
2012-146
 Dismissal
2012-145
 Dismissal
2012-144
 Dismissal
2012-143
 Dismissal
2012-142
 Dismissal
2012-141
 Dismissal
2012-140
 Dismissal
2012-139
 Dismissal
2012-138
 Dismissal
2012-137
 Dismissal
2012-134
 Dismissal
2012-133
 Dismissal
2012-132
 Dismissal
2012-131
 Dismissal
2012-129
 Dismissal
2012-127
 Dismissal
2012-126
 Dismissal
2012-125
 Dismissal
2012-124
 Dismissal
2012-123
 Dismissal
2012-122
 Dismissal
2012-121
 Dismissal
2012-120
 Dismissal
2012-119
 Dismissal
2012-117
 Dismissal
2012-116
 Dismissal
2012-115
 Dismissal
2012-114
 Dismissal
2012-113
 Dismissal
2012-112
 Dismissal
2012-111
 Dismissal
2012-109
 Dismissal
2012-107
 Dismissal
2012-106
 Dismissal
2012-105
 Dismissal
2012-103
 Dismissal
2012-102
 Dismissal
2012-101
 Dismissal
2012-100
 Dismissal
2012-099
 Dismissal
2012-098
 Dismissal
2012-097
 Dismissal
2012-096
 Dismissal
2012-095
 Dismissal
2012-093
 Dismissal
2012-092
 Dismissal
2012-090
 Dismissal
2012-089
 Dismissal
2012-088
 Dismissal
2012-087
 Dismissal
2012-086
 Dismissal
2012-085
 Dismissal
2012-083
 Dismissal
2012-082
 Dismissal
2012-081
 Dismissal
2012-080
 Dismissal
2012-079
 Dismissal
2012-078
 Dismissal
2012-077
 Dismissal
2012-076
 Dismissal
2012-075
 Dismissal
2012-074
 Dismissal
2012-073
 Dismissal
2012-071
 Dismissal
2012-070
 Dismissal
2012-069
 Dismissal
2012-068
 Dismissal
2012-067
 Dismissal
2012-066
 Dismissal
2012-065
 Dismissal
2012-064
 Dismissal
2012-063
 Dismissal
2012-062
 Dismissal
2012-061
 Dismissal
2012-060
 Dismissal
2012-059
 Dismissal
2012-058
 Dismissal
2012-057
 Dismissal
2012-055
 Dismissal
2012-054
 Dismissal
2012-053
 Dismissal
2012-050
 Dismissal
2012-049
 Dismissal
2012-048
 Dismissal
2012-047
 Dismissal
2012-046
 Dismissal
2012-045
 Dismissal
2012-044
 Dismissal
2012-043
 Dismissal
2012-042
 Dismissal
2012-041
 Dismissal
2012-040
 Dismissal
2012-039
 Dismissal
2012-038
 Dismissal
2012-037
 Dismissal
2012-036
 Dismissal
2012-035
 Dismissal
2012-034
 Dismissal
2012-033
 Dismissal
2012-032
 Dismissal
2012-031
 Dismissal
2012-030
 Dismissal
2012-028
 Dismissal
2012-027
 Dismissal
2012-026
 Dismissal
2012-024
 Dismissal
2012-023
 Dismissal
2012-022
 Dismissal
2012-021
 Dismissal
2012-020
 Dismissal
2012-019
 Dismissal
2012-018
 Dismissal
2012-017
 Dismissal
2012-016
 Dismissal
2012-013
 Dismissal
2012-011
 Dismissal
2012-010
 Dismissal
2012-009
 Dismissal
2012-008
 Dismissal
2012-007
 Dismissal
2012-006
 Dismissal
2012-005
 Dismissal
2012-003
 Dismissal
2012-002
 Dismissal
2012-001
 Dismissal