JPR Banner
Home > Judicial Performance Reports > Judicial Decisions

Judicial Decisions

This search utility below is available for decisions filed with the Arizona Supreme Court and Court of Appeals, Division I.

Click here to search Court of Appeals, Division II.
Search filter ON - Top 1000 records found    Clear search filter
Judge: Winthrop, Lawrence F.
Search Decisions

12345678910...
12/8/2022   1 CA-CR 22-0020STATE v. PEREZ AGUEDAMEMORANDUM
 Paul J. McMurdie, Author; Cynthia J. Bailey, Concur; Lawrence F. Winthrop, Concur

3/29/2022   1 CA-CV 19-0544TORRES, et al. v. JAI DININGOPINION
 Lawrence F. Winthrop, Author; Maria Elena Cruz, Concur; David B. Gass, Concur

 

1.  Whether JAI Dining waived the issue of preemption by not raising it in the superior court.

2.  Whether A.R.S. § 4-312(B) preempts Plaintiffs’ common law claims.

3/17/2022   1 CA-CR 20-0388-PRPCSTATE v. TAYLORMEMORANDUM
 Paul J. McMurdie; Cynthia J. Bailey; Lawrence F. Winthrop

12/9/2021   1 CA-CV 19-0649-FCLARCHICK v. POLLOCKOPINION
 Jennifer B. Campbell, Author; Lawrence F. Winthrop, Concur; Samuel A. Thumma, Concur

 

1. Whether the family court erred by entering a decree dissolving the parties’ marriage while retaining jurisdiction to decide property issues.

2. Whether the family court erred by precluding expert opinion valuation testimony on the basis that the expert had failed to follow all possible methodologies.

3. Whether the family court, after precluding Husband’s expert from testifying, erred by concluding there was no evidence that Wife’s business increased in value during the marriage.

4. Whether the family court erred by improperly placing the burden of proof on Husband to show a community interest in real property Wife’s LLC purchased during the marriage.

10/14/2021   1 CA-CR 20-0366STATE v. ENGLISHMEMORANDUM
 Paul J. McMurdie, Author; Cynthia J. Bailey, Concur; Lawrence F. Winthrop, Concur

10/14/2021   1 CA-CR 20-0487STATE v. ACOSTAMEMORANDUM
 Paul J. McMurdie, Author; Cynthia J. Bailey, Concur; Lawrence F. Winthrop, Concur

9/23/2021   1 CA-CR 20-0527STATE v. WATERSMEMORANDUM
 Cynthia J. Bailey, Author; Paul J. McMurdie, Concur; Lawrence F. Winthrop, Concur

8/26/2021   1 CA-CV 20-0127CANAS, et al. v. BAY ENTERTAINMENT, et al.OPINION
 Peter B. Swann, Author; Jennifer B. Campbell, Concur; Lawrence F. Winthrop, Concur

 

1. Does Arizona recognize a common law cause of action by civilians for misappropriation of name or likeness as a species of invasion of privacy? 

2. Does A.R.S. § 12-761 preempt any such common law cause of action?

8/24/2021   1 CA-TX 20-0009MESQUITE POWER v. ADOROPINION
 Paul J. McMurdie, Author; Cynthia J. Bailey, Concur; Lawrence F. Winthrop, Concur

 

Whether the Department of Revenue's obligation to provide forms is a condition precedent excusing the taxpayer’s failure to submit its 2020 valuation timely.

 

8/12/2021   1 CA-TX 20-0005BSI v. ADOTOPINION
 Lawrence F. Winthrop, Author; Paul J. McMurdie, Concur; Cynthia J. Bailey, Concur

 

1. Whether the tax court erred in concluding the term “based in” is ambiguous as used in A.R.S. § 28-8336.

2. Whether the tax court should have applied a “domiciliary analysis” to the definition of the term “based in” and applied a “totality of the circumstances” standard to that domiciliary analysis.

12345678910...