Home > Judicial Performance Reports > Judicial Decisions

Judicial Decisions

This search utility below is available for decisions filed with the Arizona Supreme Court and Court of Appeals, Division I.

Click here to search Court of Appeals, Division II.
Search filter ON - Top 1000 records found    Clear search filter
Judge: Timmer, Ann Scott
Search Decisions

12345678910...
11/23/2022   CV-21-0192-PRTIMOTHY MATTHEWS v ICA/CITY OF TUCSON/TRISTAROPINION
 Clint Bolick, Author; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; John R. Lopez, Concur; James P. Beene, Concur; William Montgomery, Concur; Kathryn H. King, Concur; Ann Scott Timmer, Concur in part; Dissent in part

 Constitutionality Decision

A.R.S. § 23-1043.01(B), which limits workers’ compensation claims for mental illnesses to those that arise from an “unexpected, unusual or extraordinary stress” situation, does not violate article 18, section 8 of the Arizona Constitution or the equal protection guarantee of article 2, section 13.

10/20/2022   CV-21-0051-PRMATTHEW CAVALLO et al v PHOENIX HEALTH PLANS INCOPINION
 Kathryn H. King, Author; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; Ann Scott Timmer, Concur; Clint Bolick, Concur; John R. Lopez, Concur; James P. Beene, Concur; William Montgomery, Concur

9/28/2022   CV-21-0205-PRTINA ZAMBRANO v M & RC II LLC et alOPINION
 Ann Scott Timmer, Author; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; John R. Lopez, Concur; James P. Beene, Concur; William Montgomery, Concur; Kathryn H. King, Dissent; Clint Bolick, Dissent

9/27/2022   CV-21-0080-PRROBERT BURNS v ARIZONA PUBLIC SERVICE CO et alOPINION
 Clint Bolick, Author; James P. Beene, Concur; William Montgomery, Concur; Kathryn H. King, Concur; Ann Scott Timmer, Dissent

 

(Amended on 09/27/2022)

9/27/2022   CR-20-0435-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v SERGIO FIERRO JROPINION
 Clint Bolick, Author; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; Ann Scott Timmer, Concur; James P. Beene, Concur; John R. Lopez, Dissent; William Montgomery, Dissent; Kathryn H. King, Dissent

9/27/2022   CV-21-0236-CQGERALD WALKER et al. v AUTO-OWNERS INSURANCE COMPOPINION
 Kathryn H. King, Author; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; Ann Scott Timmer, Concur; Clint Bolick, Concur; John R. Lopez, Concur; James P. Beene, Concur; William Montgomery, Concur

9/20/2022   CV-22-0204-AP/ELLEIBSOHN et al v HOBBS/VOTERS RIGHT TO KNOWOPINION
 Ann Scott Timmer, Author; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; Clint Bolick, Concur; John R. Lopez, Concur; James P. Beene, Concur; William Montgomery, Concur; Kathryn H. King, Concur

 Constitutionality Decision

The Secretary of State’s petition circulator registration process made it impossible for an initiative sponsoring committee to comply with the registration requirements set forth in § 19-118(B)(5).  For that reason, the Court concluded that A.R.S. § 19-118(A), which requires signature disqualification for noncompliance with § 19-118(B)(5), is unconstitutional as applied in these circumstances.

9/14/2022   CV-21-0023-PRHANI W SABA v SAWSAN KHOURYOPINION
 Robert M. Brutinel, Author; Ann Scott Timmer, Concur; Clint Bolick, Concur; John R. Lopez, Concur; James P. Beene, Concur; William Montgomery, Concur; Kathryn H. King, Concur

8/31/2022   CV-22-0018-PRKAREN FANN et al v HON. KEMP/AMERICAN OVERSIGHTOPINION
 John R. Lopez, Author; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; Ann Scott Timmer, Concur; James P. Beene, Concur; William Montgomery, Concur; Kathryn H. King, Concur; John Pelander, Concur

8/31/2022   CV-21-0024-PRLAVELLE BRIDGES v NATIONSTAR MORTGAGE LLCOPINION
 James P. Beene, Author; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; Ann Scott Timmer, Concur; Clint Bolick, Concur; John R. Lopez, Concur; William Montgomery, Concur; Kathryn H. King, Concur

12345678910...