JPR Banner
Home > Judicial Performance Reports > Judicial Decisions

Judicial Decisions

This search utility below is available for decisions filed with the Arizona Supreme Court and Court of Appeals, Division I.

Click here to search Court of Appeals, Division II.
Search filter ON - Top 1000 records found    Clear search filter
Judge: Timmer, Ann Scott
Search Decisions

12345678910...
2/23/2024   CV-23-0009-CQIn re: STEVEN R. DRUMMOND, MARY A. DRUMMONDOPINION
 James P. Beene, Author; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; Clint Bolick, Concur; John R. Lopez, Concur; William Montgomery, Concur; Kathryn H. King, Concur; Ann Scott Timmer, Dissent

2/6/2024   CV-23-0076-PRNEPTUNE SWIMMING FOUNDATION v CITY OF SCOTTSDALEOPINION
 Ann Scott Timmer, Author; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; Clint Bolick, Concur; John R. Lopez, Concur; James P. Beene, Concur; William Montgomery, Concur; Kathryn H. King, Concur

1/26/2024   CV-22-0231-PRBARRIGA v ADES/PRECISIONOPINION
 James P. Beene, Author; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; Ann Scott Timmer, Concur; Clint Bolick, Concur; John R. Lopez, Concur; William Montgomery, Concur; Kathryn H. King, Concur

1/23/2024   CR-23-0042-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v DANIEL LOUIS SANTILLANESOPINION
 Kathryn H. King, Author; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; Ann Scott Timmer, Concur; Clint Bolick, Concur; John R. Lopez, Concur; James P. Beene, Concur; John Pelander, Concur

1/10/2024   CR-23-0053-PRSTATE OF ARIZONA v JOSE ADRIAN AGUNDEZ-MARTINEZOPINION
 Ann Scott Timmer, Author; Clint Bolick, Concur; John R. Lopez, Concur; James P. Beene, Concur; William Montgomery, Concur; Kathryn H. King, Concur; Rebecca White Berch, Concur

1/9/2024   CV-22-0134-PRBECK et al v NEVILLE et alOPINION
 William Montgomery, Author; Clint Bolick, Concur; John R. Lopez, Concur; James P. Beene, Concur; Kathryn H. King, Concur; John Pelander, Concur; Ann Scott Timmer, Concur in part

12/11/2023   CV-22-0170-PRROSENBERG v SANDERSOPINION
 Kathryn H. King, Author; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; Ann Scott Timmer, Concur; Clint Bolick, Concur; John R. Lopez, Concur; James P. Beene, Concur; William Montgomery, Concur

12/5/2023   CV-22-0176-PRMCMICHAEL-GOMBAR v PHOENIX CIVIL SERVICE et alOPINION
 Ann Scott Timmer, Author; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; Clint Bolick, Concur; John R. Lopez, Concur; James P. Beene, Concur; William Montgomery, Concur; Kathryn H. King, Concur

10/16/2023   CV-22-0288-PRAVITIA v CRISIS PREPARATIONOPINION
 Clint Bolick, Author; Robert M. Brutinel, Concur; John R. Lopez, Concur; James P. Beene, Concur; William Montgomery, Concur; Kathryn H. King, Concur; Ann Scott Timmer, Concur in part; Dissent in part

 Constitutionality Decision

This ruling overturns Little v. All Phoenix South Community Mental Health Center, 186 Ariz. 97 (App. 1996), which declared A.R.S. section 36-517.02 unconstitutional.  The ruling does not opine whether its effect is to restore the statute or whether legislative action would be necessary to do so.

10/16/2023   CV-22-0142-PRTORRES et al v JAI DINING SERVICESOPINION
 Robert M. Brutinel, Author; Clint Bolick, Concur; John R. Lopez, Concur; James P. Beene, Concur; Ann Scott Timmer, Dissent

 Constitutionality Decision

We hold that A.R.S. § 4-312(B), which limits dram-shop liability to actions brought under § 4-311, does not conflict with article 18, § 6 of the Arizona Constitution (known as the Anti-abrogation Clause) because dram-shop actions are not based in a right of action recognized by pre-statehood common law.

12345678910...