Judicial Report

Home > Performance Reports > Judicial Reports

Judicial Reports

Commission number votes may vary based upon abstentions. Voting abstentions are procedural matters within the
Commission and should not be viewed in any way as a negative factor with respect to a judge's performance.


Hon. Arthur T. Anderson	2018 Attorney Survey Responses
Key: SU = Superior VG = Very Good SA = Satisfactory PO = Poor UN = Unsatisfactory

	UN		PO		SA		VG		SU		Mean	Total	No Resp
1. Legal Ability	Num.	Pct.	Num.	Pct.	Num.	Pct.	Num.	Pct.	Num.	Pct.
20180093. Legal reasoning ability	0	0%	4	22%	2	11%	4	22%	8	44%	2.89	18	0
20180094. Knowledge of substantive law	0	0%	5	28%	2	11%	3	17%	8	44%	2.78	18	0
20180095. Knowledge of rules of evidence	0	0%	3	18%	2	12%	5	29%	7	41%	2.94	17	0
20180096. Knowledge of rules of procedure	1	6%	3	17%	4	22%	3	17%	7	39%	2.67	18	0
Category Total	1	1%	15	21%	10	14%	15	21%	30	42%	2.82	71
2. Integrity
20180097. Basic fairness and impartiality	3	17%	1	6%	2	11%	7	39%	5	28%	2.56	18	0
20180098. Equal treatment regardless of race	1	6%	2	11%	2	11%	8	44%	5	28%	2.78	18	0
20180099. Equal treatment regardless of gender	1	6%	2	11%	3	17%	7	39%	5	28%	2.72	18	0
20180100. Equal treatment regardless of religion	0	0%	0	0%	2	15%	5	38%	6	46%	3.31	13	0
20180101. Equal treatment regardless of national origin	1	6%	1	6%	2	13%	6	38%	6	38%	2.94	16	0
20180102. Equal treatment regardless of disability	0	0%	0	0%	2	15%	5	38%	6	46%	3.31	13	0
20180103. Equal treatment regardless of age	0	0%	2	13%	3	19%	6	38%	5	31%	2.88	16	0
20180104. Equal treatment regardless of sexual orientation	0	0%	0	0%	2	17%	5	42%	5	42%	3.25	12	0
20180105. Equal treatment regardless of economic status	1	6%	0	0%	2	13%	8	50%	5	31%	3.00	16	0
Category Total	7	5%	8	6%	20	14%	57	41%	48	34%	2.94	140
3. Communication
20180106. Clear and logical oral communications and directions	1	6%	3	17%	3	17%	4	22%	7	39%	2.72	18	0
20180107. Clear and logical written decisions	1	7%	2	13%	2	13%	4	27%	6	40%	2.80	15	0
20180108. Gave all parties an adequate opportunity to be heard	3	17%	1	6%	1	6%	5	28%	8	44%	2.78	18	0
Category Total	5	10%	6	12%	6	12%	13	25%	21	41%	2.76	51
4. Temperament
20180109. Understanding and compassion	1	6%	2	11%	2	11%	6	33%	7	39%	2.89	18	0
20180110. Dignified	2	11%	3	17%	3	17%	5	28%	5	28%	2.44	18	0
20180111. Courteous	0	0%	3	17%	3	17%	7	39%	5	28%	2.78	18	0
20180112. Conduct that promoted public confidence in the court and judge''s ability	3	17%	1	6%	4	22%	5	28%	5	28%	2.44	18	0
20180113. Patient	2	12%	2	12%	2	12%	5	29%	6	35%	2.65	17	0
Category Total	8	9%	11	12%	14	16%	28	31%	28	31%	2.64	89
5. Admin Performance
20180114. Punctual in conducting proceedings	3	19%	6	38%	4	25%	0	0%	3	19%	1.62	16	0
20180115. Maintained proper control over courtroom	2	13%	2	13%	5	31%	3	19%	4	25%	2.31	16	0
20180116. Prompt in making rulings and rendering decisions	1	7%	1	7%	5	33%	5	33%	3	20%	2.53	15	0
20180117. Was prepared for the proceedings	2	13%	1	6%	6	38%	4	25%	3	19%	2.31	16	0
20180118. Efficient management of the calendar	4	25%	6	38%	3	19%	0	0%	3	19%	1.50	16	0
Category Total	12	15%	16	20%	23	29%	12	15%	16	20%	2.05	79
6. Settlement Activities
20180119. Appropriately promoted or conducted settlement	0	0%	0	0%	1	17%	1	17%	4	67%	3.50	6	0
Category Total	0	0%	0	0%	1	17%	1	17%	4	67%	3.50	6