Search 

Azcourts.gov

Arizona Judicial Branch

Agendas and Cases before the Court

 

 
NOTE:  Cases are listed until the issuance of the Court's mandate. 
 
Tuesday, March 20, 2018 - Petitions for Review 
 
BUTLER LAW et al v HON. HIGGINS/WINSLOW MEMORIAL 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CV-17-0119-PR 
Oral Argument held on 10/24/2017 
Case Summary

Petition for review granted on the following issues as reframed by the Court on 9/12/2017: 

1.  Whether a limited liability company constitutes an “other corporation[]” for purposes of the venue exception in A.R.S. section 12-401(18).

2.  Whether a law firm’s fee agreement may constitute a contract “in writing to perform an obligation in one county” binding against the partners of such firm so as to subject them to the venue exception in A.R.S. section 12-401(5). 

 
BRENDA D. v DCS/Z.D. 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CV-17-0136-PR 
Oral Argument held on 11/14/2017
Case Summary 

Petition for Review granted on the following two issues on 10/17/2017:

(1) Did the court of appeals err in holding that, for purposes of A.R.S. section 8-863(C) and Arizona Rule of Juvenile Procedure 66(D)(2), “a parent has not ‘failed to appear’ simply because he or she is tardy without good cause”?

(2) Did the court of appeals err in holding that the parent’s due process rights were violated by the juvenile court placing restrictions on counsel before the parent’s arrival at the hearing and refusing to allow the parent to testify based on a tardy arrival? 

Opinion issued from the Court of Appeals, Division One, Case No. 1 CA-JV 16-0277 
 
BSI HOLDINGS LLC v ADOT 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CV-17-0241-PR 
Oral Argument to be held on 2/21/2018
Case Summary
Petition for Review granted on 12/11/2017 
Opinion issued from the Court of Appeals, Division One, Case No. 1 CA-TX 16-0003 
 
LISA FRIEDMAN v DAVID C ROELS JR et al 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CV-17-0225-PR 
Oral Argument to be held on 4/16/2018 
Case Summary not yet available 
Petition for Review granted on 2/13/2018 
Opinion issued from the Court of Appeals, Division One, 2 CA-CV 16-0029 
 
DIANA GLAZER v STATE 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CV-17-0229-PR 
Oral Argument held on 1/23/2018
Case Summary
Petition for Review granted on 12/11/2017 
Opinion issued from the Court of Appeals, Division One, Case No. 1 CA-CV 16-0416 
 
PABLO GONZALES et al v QUOC NGUYEN et al 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CV-17-0117-PR 
Oral Argument held on 12/12/2017 
Case Summary
Petition for Review granted as to Issue 1 only on 11/16/2017 
Memorandum Decision issued from the Court of Appeals, Division One, Case No. 1 CA-CV 16-0141 
 
J HAMBLEN et ux v HON. HATCH/WINSLOW MEMORIAL 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CV-16-0260-PR 
Oral Argument held on 5/9/2017
Case Summary
Petition for Review granted on 3/14/2017 
 
KNIGHTBROOK v PAYLESS CAR RENTAL/PCR VENTURE 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CV-17-0156-CQ 
Opinion issued on 2/8/2018 
Oral Argument held on 10/3/2017 
Case Summary not yet available 
Jurisdiction Accepted on 6/29/2017 
 
LEGACY FOUNDATION ACTION v CITIZENS CLEAN ELECTION 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CV-16-0306-PR 
Opinion issued on 1/25/2018 
Oral Argument held on 9/11/2017
Case Summary
Petition for Review granted on 4/18/2017 
Memorandum Decision issued from the Court of Appeals, Division One, No. 1 CA-CV 15-0455 
 
KIMBERLY McLAUGHLIN v HON. JONES/SUZAN McLAUGHLIN 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CV-16-0266-PR 
Opinion issued on 9/19/2017 
Oral Argument held on 6/27/2017
Case Summary
Petition for Review granted on 4/18/2017 
Opinion issued from the Court of Appeals, Division Two, No. 2 CA-SA 16-0035 
 
MERTOLA LLC v ALBERTO J SANTOS/ARLENE SANTOS 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CV-17-0109-PR 
Oral Argument held on 11/7/2017
Case Summary 
Petition for Review granted on 9/12/2017 
Opinion issued from the Court of Appeals, Division One, Case No. 1 CA-CV 16-0168 
 
JAMES MORRENO v HON. BRICKNER/STATE/MONTGOMERY 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CV-17-0193-SA 
Oral Argument held on 10/4/2017 
Case Summary not yet available 
Jurisdiction Accepted on 8/30/2017 
 
ERNEST QUIROZ et ux v ALCOA INC et al 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CV-16-0248-PR 
Oral Argument held on 4/25/2017
Case Summary
Petition for Review granted on 2/14/2017 
Opinion issued from the Court of Appeals, Division One, No 1 CA-CV 15-0083 
 
ROBIN SILVER et al v PUEBLO DEL SOL WATER CO et al 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CV-16-0294-PR 
Oral Argument to be held on 3/8/2018
Case Summary not yet available 

Petitions for Review granted on the following issues on 12/11/2017:   

 1. Whether the court of appeals erred to the extent it requires ADWR on remand to consider BLM’s federal reserved water rights under ADWR’s regulation governing the physical availability of a groundwater supply, A.A.C 12-15-716(B).

 2. Whether, under A.R.S. section 45-108, ADWR may designate Pueblo’s watersupply as adequate without evaluating potential legal conflicts between Pueblo’s groundwater pumping and BLM’s senior federal reserved water rights that could render Pueblo’s water supply legally unavailable, solely because those water rights have not been adjudicated.

 3. Whether the private attorney general doctrine is applicable and permits anaward of fees against Pueblo. 

Opinion from the Court of Appeals, Division One, No. 1 CA-CV 14-0811 
 
SOLARCITY CORPORATION/SUNRUN INC v ADOR 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CV-17-0231-PR 
Oral Argument held on 1/25/2018
Case Summary
Petition for Review granted on 12/11/2017 
Opinion from the Court of Appeals, Division One, No. 1 CA-TX 15-0008 
 
STATE v JOHN MICHAEL ALLEN 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-17-0556-AP 
Oral Argument not yet scheduled 
Case Summary not yet available  
 
STATE v SAMMANTHA LUCILLE REBECCA ALLEN 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-17-0368-AP 
Oral Argument not yet scheduled 
Case Summary not yet available  
 
STATE v HON. GATES/APOLINAR ALTAMIRANO 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-17-0326-PR 
Opinion issued on 2/16/2018 
Oral Argument held on 11/7/2017
Case Summary
Petition for Review granted on 9/12/2017 
 
STATE v JASON EUGENE BUSH 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-11-0107-AP 
Oral Argument not yet scheduled 
Case Summary not yet available 
 
STATE v ANTAJUAN STEWART CARSON JR 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-17-0116-PR 
Oral Argument held on 12/12/2017 
Case Summary
Petition for Review granted as to Issue 1 only on 11/16/2017 
Opinion issued from the Court of Appeals, Division Two, Case No. 2 CA-CR 15-0218 
 
STATE v ALAN MATTHEW CHAMPAGNE 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-17-0425-AP 
Oral Argument not yet scheduled 
Case Summary not yet available  
 
STATE v DARREL SCOTT FRANCIS 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-17-0062-PR 
Opinion issued on 2/5/2018 
Oral Argument held on 10/24/2017
Case Summary
Petition for Review granted on 8/30/2017 
Opinion issued from the Court of Appeals, Division One, No. 1 CA-CR 16-0051 
 
STATE v HON. WEIN/HENDERSON/GOODMAN 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-17-0221-PR 
Oral Argument tto be held on 2/22/2018 
Case Summary
Petition for Review granted on 1/9/2018 
Opinion issued from the Court of Appeals, Division One, Case Nos. 1 CA-SA 17-0072 and 1 CA-SA 17-0077 
 
STATE v CHARLES MICHAEL HEDLUND 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-93-0377-AP 
Oral Argument not yet scheduled 
Case Summary not yet available  
 
STATE v ANTHONY LITO HERNANDEZ 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-17-0325-PR 
Oral Argument held on 12/12/2017 
Case Summary
Petition for Review granted on 11/16/2017 
Opinion issued from the Court of Appeals, Division Two, Case No. 2 CA-CR 15-0229 
 
STATE v ABEL DANIEL HIDALGO
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-15-0049-AP 
Opinion issued on 3/15/2017 
Oral Argument held on 12/13/2016 
Case Summary
 
STATE v JAMES CLAYTON JOHNSON 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-16-0261-AP 
Oral Argument not yet scheduled 
Case Summary not yet available  
 
STATE v ANDRE LEE JUWAUN MAESTAS 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-17-0193-PR 
Oral Argument to be held on 2/22/2018
Case Summary
Petition for Review granted on 1/9/2018 
Opinion issued from the Court of Appeals, Division One, Case No. 1 CA-CR 15-0724 
 
STATE v MARICOPA COUNTY COLLEGE BOARD et al 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CV-17-0215-PR 
Oral Argument to be held on 4/2/2018
Case Summary not yet available
Petitions for Review granted as to Issue 1 only on 2/13/2018 
Opinion issued from the Court of Appeals, Division One, 1 CA-CV 15-0498 
 
STATE v JAMES ERIN McKINNEY 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-93-0362-AP 
Oral Argument not yet scheduled 
Case Summary not yet available  
 
STATE v KEVIN ARTICE MILES 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-16-0021-PC 
Oral Argument held on 10/3/2017 
Case Summary
Petition for Review granted on 8/30/2017 
 
STATE v THOMAS MICHAEL RILEY 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-15-0411-AP
Oral Argument not yet scheduled
Case Summary not yet available 
 
STATE v JASPER PHILLIP RUSHING 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-15-0268-AP 
Opinion issued on 11/6/2017 
Oral Argument held on 9/13/2017
Case Summary
 
STATE v DAUNTORIAN LYDEL SANDERS 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-14-0302-AP 
Oral Argument not yet scheduled 
Case Summary not yet available 
 
STATE v PRESTON ALTON STRONG 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-17-0201-AP 
Oral Argument not yet scheduled 
Case Summary not yet available 
 
STATE v FRANCISCO MIGUEL URREA 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-17-0261-PR 
Oral Argument to be held on 4/16/2018
Case Summary not yet available 
Petition for Review granted on 2/13/2018 
Opinion issued from the Court of Appeals, Division Two, No. 2 CA-CR 15-0416 
 
STATE v JOSE ALEJANDRO ACUNA VALENZUELA
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-14-0351-AP 
Oral Argument not yet scheduled 
Case Summary not yet available 
 
STATE v DARREN LEE WINEGARDNER 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CR-17-0269-PR 
Oral Argument held on 1/25/2018
Case Summary
Petition for Review granted on 12/11/2017 
Opinion issued from the Court of Appeals, Division Two, Case No. 2 CA-CR 16-0110 
 
TIFFANY TAYLOR v THOMAS PANDOLA 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CV-16-0240-PR 
Opinion issued on 1/26/2018 
Oral Argument held on 9/13/2017
Case  Summary
Petition for Review granted as to this issue:  "Does the Arizona Uniform Interstate Family Support Act, A.R.S. §§ 25-1201 to 25-1342 (2004), and/or federal law, including the Federal Aid to Needy Families with Children statute, 42 U.S.C. § 666, require a court to confirm the alleged arrearages in a Notice of Registration if the non-registering party fails to timely object?” on 4/18/2017 
Opinion issued from the Court of Appeals, Division One, No. 1 CA-CV 15-0191 FC 
 
DENNIS TEUFEL v AMERICAN FAMILY/KERRY HANSON 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CV-17-0190-PR 
Oral Argument to be held on 4/2/2018
Case Summary not yet available 
Petition for Review granted on 2/13/2018 
Memorandum Decision issued from the Court of Appeals, Division One, 1 CA-CV 15-0736 
 
MARIA CARMEN ZUBIA v DAVID SHAPIRO et al 
Arizona Supreme Court No. CV-16-0255-PR 
Opinion issued on 1/12/2018 
Oral Argument held on 6/27/2017 
Case Summary
Petition for Review granted as to Issue A only on 4/18/2017 
Memorandum Decision issued from the Court of Appeals, Division One, No. 1 CA-CV 15-0404 
 
NOTE:  Cases are listed until the issuance of the Court's mandate.
 
 
Notice: While the clerk's office maintains quality control measures on the information posted, some errors may occur. All posted information is subject to change or amendment.