Clerk of the Court banner
HomeAZ Supreme Court > Clerk of the Arizona Supreme Court > Agendas and Cases

Agendas and Cases before the Court
 


While the Clerk's Office maintains quality control measures on the information posted, some errors may occur. All posted information is subject to change or amendment.



Agendas
 

Notice: Agendas are listed below until publishing of the Court's minutes

 

Tuesday, December 6, 2022 - Petitions for Review

Tuesday, December 6, 2022 - Petitions for Review

Tuesday, December 6, 2022 - Motions

Tuesday, December 6, 2022 - Rules 

Granted Cases (Pending Decisions by the Court)

Notice: Cases are listed until the issuance of the Clerk's mandate.

Case Title Case No. Additional Information
AZ Petition Partners LLC v Hon. Thompson/State CR-22-0154-PR

Oral Argument to be held on 1/19/2023

 

Case Summary not yet available

 

Petition for Review granted as to issue one only on 11/1/2022

 

Opinion Issued from Court of Appeals, Division One, Case No. 1 CA-SA-21-0170

 

 

Jacob Laurence et al v Salt River Project et al CV-21-0292-PR

Oral Argument to be held on 12/13/2022

 

Case Summary not yet available

 

Petition for Review granted on 10/12/2022

 

Memorandum Decision Issued from the Court of Appeals, Division One, Case No. 1 CA-CV-21-0100

 

 

Brionna J. v DCS/A.V. CV-22-0158-PR

Oral Argument to be held on 1/10/2023

 

Case Summary not yet available

 

Petition for Review granted on 10/12/2022

 

Opinion Issued from Court of Appeals, Division One, Case No. 1 CA-JV-21-0039

 

 

 

Lane Draper v Hon. Gentry/State/Nez CR-22-0175-PR

Oral Argument to be held 12/8/2022

 

Case Summary

 

Petition for Review granted on 9/13/2022

 

 

State v Tunkey et al CV-22-0128-PR

Oral Argument to be held 12/8/2022

 

Case Summary

 

Petition for Review granted on 9/13/2022

 

Memorandum Decision issued from the Court of Appeals, Division One, Case No.  1 CA-TX-21-0006

 

Carlos Cruz v Hon. Blair/State of Arizona CR-22-0123-PR

Oral Argument held on 10/24/2022

 

Case Summary

 

Petition for Review granted as to issues 1 and 3 only on 08/23/2022

 

 

In Re Pima County Mental Health No. 20200860221 CV-22-0057-PR

Oral Argument held on10/24/2022

 

Case Summary

 

Petition for Review granted on 08/23/2022

 

Opinion from the Court of Appeals, Division Two, Case No. 2 CA-MH 2021-0003

 

Barbara Sowards v Tommy Sowards CV-22-0065-PR

Oral Argument to be held 11/09/2022 **(OA on the Road- U of A, Tucson)**

 

Case Summary

 

Petition for Review granted on 08/23/2022 

 

Memorandum Decision issued from Court of Appeals, Division One, Case No. 1 CA-CV-21-0098

 

State of Arizona v Kevin Harry Moninger CR-21-0239-PR

Oral Argument to be held 11/09/2022 **(OA on the Road- U of A, Tucson)**

 

Case Summary

 

Petition for Review granted on 08/23/2022

 

Opinion from the Court of Appeals, Division One, Case No. 1 CA-CR-19-0353

 

Legacy Foundation Action v Citizens Clean Election CV-22-0041-PR

Oral Argument to be held 11/15/2022

 

Case Summary

 

Petition for Review granted on 08/23/2022

 

Opinion from the Court of Appeals, Division One, Case No. 1 CA-CV-19-0773

 

Puente et al v AZ State Legislature CV-22-0069-PR

Oral Argument to be held 11/15/2022

 

Case Summary

 

Petition for Review granted on 08/23/2022

 

Opinion from the Court of Appeals, Division One, Case No. 1 CA-CV-20-0710

 

Advanced Property Tax v Jorge Othon and Spouse CV-21-0277-PR

Oral Argument to be held 11/17/2022 **(OA on the Road- South Mountain Community College)**

 

Case Summary

 

Petition for Review granted on 08/23/2022

 

Opinion from the Court of Appeals, Division Two, Case No. 2 CA-CV-2021-0001

Fidelity National v Osborn III Partners LLC et al CV-21-0086-PR

Oral Argument to be held 11/17/2022 **(OA on the Road- South Mountain Community College)**

 

Case Summary

 

Petition for Review granted on 08/23/2022

 

Opinion from the Court of Appeals, Division One, Case No. 1 CA-CV-18-0040

Robert Burns v Arizona Public Service Co et al CV-21-0080-PR Oral Argument held on 3/8/2022

Case Summary

Petition for Review granted as to Issues #1 and #2 only on 12/7/2021

Opinion from the Court of Appeals, Division One, Case No. 1 CA-CV 19-0183
     
Matthew Cavallo et al v Phoenix Health Plans Inc CV-21-0051-PR Oral Argument held on 5/17/2022

Case Summary

Petition for Review granted as to this issue as rephrased on 3/1/2022: “Were the jury instructions on contract waiver and mitigation of damages proper in this bad faith tort case?”

Opinion issued by the Court of Appeals, Division One, Case No.  1 CA-CV-20-0167
     
Harris/Heartmedia v Hon. Randall Warner/McCarthy CV-21-0242-PR Oral Argument held on 4/14/2022

Case Summary

Petition for Review granted on 1/4/2022
     
Timothy Matthews v ICA/City of Tucson/Tristar CV-21-0192-PR Oral Argument held on 4/19/2022

Case Summary

Petition for Review granted as to this issue as rephrased on 2/8/2022:  Is A.R.S. § 23-1043.01(B) unconstitutional as applied to claimants who work in high-stress occupations such as law enforcement?

Opinion from the Court of Appeals, Division Two, Case No. 2 CA-IC 20-0001
     
Hani W Saba v Sawsan Khoury CV-21-0023-PR Oral Argument held on 10/7/2021

Case Summary

Petition for Review granted as to Issue 1 only on 8/24/2021

Opinion issued on issued from the Court of Appeals, Division One, Case No. 1 CA-CV 19-0609 FC
     

Southern Arizona Home Builders v Town of Marana

CV-21-0211-PR

Oral Argument held on 6/30/2022

 

Case Summary 

 

Petition for Review granted on 4/5/2022

 

Opinion from the Court of Appeals, Division Two, Case No. 2 CA-CV 20-0087

Staker & Parson Companies v Scottsdale Insurance Co CV-21-0256-CQ Oral Argument held on 4/14/2022

Case Summary

Certified Question accepted on 1/4/2022
     
State v Hons. Brearcliffe/Vasquez et al CV-21-0174-SA Oral Argument held on 2/10/2022

Case Summary not yet available

Jurisdiction accepted on 11/2/2021
     
Eva Cornell v Desert Financial Credit Union et al CV-22-0071-CQ

Oral Argument held on 10/12/2022

 

Case Summary

 

Certified Question accepted on 05/03/2022

State v Jordan Christopher Ewer CR-21-0059-PR Oral Argument held on 1/25/2022

Case Summary

Petition for Review granted as to this rephrased issue on 11/2/2021: Whether a jury instruction on the justification defense of self-defense may incorporate the use of force by both the defendant and the victim as suggested by the language of A.R.S. sec. 13-404(A) or refer only to the defendant as set forth in RAJI Ch. 4.

Opinion from the Court of Appeals, Division Two, Case No. 2 CA-CR 19-0162
State v Sergio Fierro Jr CR-20-0435-PR Oral Argument held on 11/16/2021

Case Summary

Petition for Review granted as to these rephrased issues on 8/24/2021: 1. How should trial courts instruct juries on attempted second-degree murder? 2. Did the trial court’s fundamental error in instructing the jury on attempted second-degree murder prejudice the defendant?

Memorandum Decision issued from the Court of Appeals, Division Two, Case No. 2 CA-CR 19-0161
State v Beau John Greene CR-21-0082-PC Oral Argument held on 3/8/2022

Case Summary

Petition for Review granted on 1/4/2022
     
State v Nicolas Luviano CR-21-0329-PR Oral Argument held on 5/17/2022

Case Summary

Petition for Review granted as to this issue as rephrased on 3/1/2022: “What standard governs whether a statute describes a single unified offense or separate offenses, and how does that apply in this case?”

Opinion issued by the Court of Appeals, Division 2, Case No. 2 CA-CR 19-0102
     

State v Bobby Charles Purcell and

State v Scott Lee Deshaw (Consolidated)

CR-21-0398-PR

          and

CR-21-0400-PR

  (Consolidated)

Oral Argument  held on 10/12/2022

 

Case Summary

 

Petition for Review granted as to Issue one only on 4/5/2022

     
State v Preston Alton Strong CR-17-0201-AP Oral Argument held on 5/5/2020

Case Summary

 

   
Swift Transportation Co of AZ v Hon. Carman et al CV-20-0119-PR Oral Argument held on 11/19/2020

Case Summary

Petition for Review granted on 8/25/2020
     
Gerald Walker et al v Auto-Owners Insurance Comp CV-21-0236-CQ Oral Argument held on 4/12/2022

Case Summary

Certified Question accepted on 1/4/2022
     
Antoinette Windhurst v ADOC et al CV-21-0288-PR

Oral Argument held on 6/28/2022

 

Case Summary

 

Petition for Review granted on 4/5/2022

 

Opinion from the Court of Appeals, Division Two, Case No. 2 CA-CV 20-0162

Tina Zambrano v M & RC II LLC et al CV-21-0205-PR Oral Argument held on 5/19/22

Case Summary

Petition for Review granted on 3/1/2022

Opinion issued by the Court of Appeals, Division One, Case No.  1 CA-CV-19-0635