Home > News & Information > High Profile Cases > CV-21-0058
Karen Fann, et al. v. State of Arizona and Invest in Education

Case Number: CV-21-0058-T/AP
Case Title: Karen Fann, et al. v. State of Arizona and Invest in Education
Filing Date: 02/26/2021
 

Senate President Karen Fann and others appealed a trial court decision denying their request to enjoin Proposition 208, “Invest in Education.” The Court granted the petition to transfer and held oral argument on April 20, 2021.

 
CV-21-0058-T/AP
Last Updated Document Remark
09/17/2021 Order Re Renewed Request for Attorneys' Fees and Costs Unofficial copy
08/19/2021 Opinion Unofficial copy
07/13/2021 Intervenor-Defendants/Appellees' Unopposed Motion for Procedural Order to Amend Caption Unofficial copy
07/13/2021 Intervenor-Defendants/Appellees' Notice of Supplemental Authority and Request for Judicial Notice Unofficial copy
06/25/2021 Appellants' Notice of Filing Notice of Supplemental Authority in Superior Court Unofficial copy
06/17/2021 Intervenor-Defendants/Appellees' Second Notice Regarding Trial Court Proceedings Unofficial copy
04/16/2021 Certificate Unofficial copy
04/16/2021 Appellants Response to Filings of Supplemental Authority Unofficial copy
04/16/2021 Request to Photograph Oral Arguments Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Intervenor-Defendants/Appellees' Notice of Citation to Supplemental Authority Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Compliance Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Intervenor-Defendants/Appellees' Notice of Citation to Supplemental Authority Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Exhibit 1 Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Minute Entry Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Compliance Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Appellees Invest in Education (Sponsored by AEA and Stand for Children) and David Lujan's Combined Response to Amicus Briefs in Support of Appellants Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Brief of Amicus Curiae Tax Professor Erin Scharff Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Appellants' Response to Amicus Curiae Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Civil Transfer Appeal Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Asc Order Recusing Justice Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Compliance Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Joint Notice Regarding Blanket Consent for Amicus Curiae Briefs Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Compliance Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Amici Curiae Brief of Save Our Schools Arizona, Education Law Center, and the Southern Poverty Law Center in Support of Defendants/Appellees Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Joint Notice Regarding Blanket Consent for Amicus Curiae Briefs Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Brief of the Arizona Tax Research Association and Arizona Chamber of Commerce and Industry as Amicus Curiae in Support of Appellants Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Compliance Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Amici Brief in Support of Plaintiffs-Appellants Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Brief of Economists Elliott Pollack and Alan Maguire as Amici Curiae in Support of Reversal Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Compliance Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Allowance Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Compliance Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Compliance Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Consent by All Parties for Brief of Amicus Curiae Arizona Farm Bureau Federation in Support of Plaintiffs/Appellants' Opening Brief Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Compliance Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Brief of amici curiae Senate Minority Leader Rebecca Rios and House Minority Leader Reginald Bolding Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Compliance Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Consent Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Brief of Amicus Curiae Arizona Farm Bureau Federation in Support of Plaintiffs'/Appellants' Opening Brief Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Appendix to Brief of Amicus Curiae in Support of Plaintiffs/Appellants Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Brief of Americans for Tax Reform and Arizona Small Business Association as Amicus Curiae in Support of Appellants Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Appellants' Reply Brief Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Allowance Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Compliance Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Consent of All Parties to File Amicus Brief Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Appendix Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Civil Transfer Appeal Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Brief of Amicus Curiae in Support of Plaintiffs/Appellants Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Compliance Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Compliance Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Joint Notice Regarding Blanket Consent for Amicus Curiae Briefs Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Brief of Amicus Curiae Kathy Hoffman in Her Official Capacity as Superintendent of Public Instruction Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Compliance Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Joint Notice Regarding Blanket Consent for Amicus Curiae Briefs Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Compliance Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Brief of Amicus Curiae Arizona School Boards Association in Support of Affirmance Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Compliance Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Certificate of Allowance Unofficial copy
04/09/2021 Brief of Amicus Curiae Arizona Business Leaders in Support of Plaintiffs/Appellants with Approval of the Parties Unofficial copy
03/16/2021 Combined Answering Brief and Separate Appendix of Appellees Invest in Education (Sponsored by AEA and Stand For Children) and David Lujan Unofficial copy
03/15/2021 Answering Brief by Appellees State of Arizona and Arizona Department of Revenue Unofficial copy
03/15/2021 Appendix to Answering Brief by Appellees State of Arizona and Arizona Department of Revenue Unofficial copy
03/04/2021 Statement of Amici Curie Governor Douglas A. Ducey and the Office of Strategic Planning and Budgeting Re: ARCAP 16(b)(1)(B) Unofficial copy
03/04/2021 Rule 16 Joint Report Unofficial copy
03/04/2021 Certificate of Compliance Unofficial copy
03/04/2021 Asc Order Granting Transfer and Set Unofficial copy
03/04/2021 Plaintiffs/Appellants' Notice of Errata Re: Certificate of Service of Appellants' Petition for Transfer Unofficial copy
03/04/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
03/04/2021 Brief of Amici Curiae Governor Douglas A. Ducey and the Office of Strategic Planning & Budgeting Unofficial copy
03/04/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
03/04/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
03/04/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
03/04/2021 Exhibit A Amended Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
03/04/2021 Defendant/Appellee Kimberly Yee's Joinder in Plaintiffs Petition for Transfer Unofficial copy
03/04/2021 Certificate of Service Unofficial copy
03/04/2021 Certificate of Compliance Unofficial copy
03/04/2021 Response to Appellants' Petition to Transfer Unofficial copy
03/04/2021 Petition for Transfer Unofficial copy
03/04/2021 Order Re: Motion to Suspend and Expedite Unofficial copy