2004 Case Summaries

These web pages are designed to provide members of the news media and other interested parties with summaries of Oral Arguments that will be or have been heard by the justices of the Arizona Supreme Court.

These summaries were prepared by the Arizona Supreme Court Staff Attorney’s Office and the Administrative Office of the Courts solely for educational purposes. They are not to be considered official commentaries by the court or any member thereof or part of any brief, memorandum or other pleading filed in these cases.

December 7, 2004 Case Summaries: CR-02-0402-AP State of Arizona v. Frank Winfield Anderson; and CV-04-0103CQ Mark V. Scheehle v. Justices of Arizona Supreme Court

December 2, 2004 Case Summary: CV-04-0146-PR Safeway Insurance v. Peter A. Guerrero et al.

November 4, 2004 Case Summaries: CV-04-0033-PR City of Tucson v. Clear Channel Outdoor Inc.; CV-04-0114-PR Charles Phelps v. Firebird Raceway Inc.; and CR-04-0234-PR State of Arizona v. Sudden Rio Stroud

October 28, 2004 Case Summaries: CV-04-0037-PR J. Derendal v. Hon. D Griffith/Phoenix Prosecutors; and CV-04-0046-PR Maricopa Sheriff v. Maricopa Merit System et al.

September 28, 2004 Case Summaries: CV-04-0153-CQ Sidney Lachter et al. v. James M. Smith; and CR-03-0160-AP State of Arizona v. Albert Martinez Carreon

September 23, 2004 Case Summaries: CV-04-0053-PR Daniel Cornell et al. v. Roger Lee Groves et al.; and CV-03-0255-PR State of Arizona v. Hon. Michael J. Brown/McMullen

June 1, 2004 Case Summaries: CR-01-0421-AP State of Arizona v. Michael Joe Murdaugh; and CR-02-0044-AP State of Arizona v. Robert Joe Moody

May 27, 2004 Case Summaries: SB-04-0015-R In the Matter of Richard B. Arrotta; and CV-04-0032-SA Kerby James McKaney v. Hon. Foreman/State

April 29, 2004 Case Summaries: CV-03-0379-PR In RE the Commitment of Robert Flemming; and CV-03-0397-PR S. Zajac/E. Zajac v. City of Casa Grande/Wal-Mart

April 21, 2004 Case Summary: CV-03-0348-PR Aileen H. Char Life Int et al. v. Maricopa Co. et al.

March 25, 2004 Case Summaries: CV-03-0321-PR Arizona Water Co. v. Arizona Dept of Water Resources et al.; and CR-03-0332-PR State of Arizona v. David Heran Aguilar

March 23, 2004 Case Summaries: CV-03-0351-PR Kenneth Phillips v. Hon. Louis Araneta/State of Arizona; and CV-03-0290-PR American Pepper Supply v. Federal Insurance Company

February 20, 2004 Case Summaries: CV-03-0310-PR Robin Pleak et al. v. Entrada Property Assn et al.; and CV-03-0279-PR N. Valley Emergency v. Hon. Santana/Team Physicians

February 18, 2004 Case Summaries: CR-03-0284-PR State of Arizona v. Daniel John Smyers; and CV-03-0180-PR Gilbert Navarro Galaz v. Terry L. Stewart

January 15, 2004 Case Summary: CV-03-0250-PR State of Arizona ex rel ADOR v. Capitol Castings Inc.

January 13, 2004 Case Summaries: CR-03-0326-PR State of Arizona v. Victor Torres; and CV-03-0228-PR In RE Andre M.