2024 Case Summaries


These web pages are designed to provide members of the news media and other interested parties with summaries of Oral Argument that will be or have been heard by the justices of the Arizona Supreme Court.

These summaries were prepared by the Arizona Supreme Court Staff Attorneys' Office and the Administrative Office of the Courts solely for educational purposes.  They are not to be considered official commentaries by the court or any member thereof or part of any brief, memorandum or other pleading filed in these cases. 

December 10, 2024 Case Summary: CR-20-0031-AP State of Arizona v. Edward Littleton McCauley

December 4, 2024 Case Summary: CV-24-0114-PR In re Termination of Parental Rights as to M.N. 

November 21, 2024 Case Summaries: CV-23-0262-PR Robin Roebuck v. Mayo Clinic, et al.; CV-24-0091-PR Gabriel Garibay et al. v. Hon. Johnson/Fox

October 30, 2024 Case Summaries: CV-24-0013-PR Sanchez et al v Maricopa County; CV-24-0049-PR Jose R. Aroca et al v Tang Investment

October 29, 2024 Case Summaries: CV-24-0079-PR Term of Parental Rights as to BW; CV-23-0292-PR State of Arizona v. Foothills Reserve Master Owners Association; CV-23-0263-PR In the Matter of William John Chalmers

September 26, 2024 Case Summary: CR-23-0236-PR State of Arizona v. Ian Mitcham

September 24, 2024 Case Summaries: CR-23-0215-PR State of Arizona v. Giovani F. Melendez; CV-23-0164-PR Centerpoint Mechanic Lien Claims, LLC v. Commonwealth Land Title Insurance Company

September 17, 2024 Case Summaries: CV-23-0228-PR State Farm Automobile v. Jacey Lee Orlando; CV-23-0284-PR City of Mesa/Gustavo Williams v. Hon. Timothy Ryan/Philip Rogers

June 13, 2024 Case Summaries: CR-23-0252-PR Lisa Gilpin v. Hon. Danielle Harris/ Marcos Jerell Martinez; CR-22-0106-AP State of Arizona v. Christopher Montoya

May 14, 2024 Case Summary: CV-23-0283-PR San Diego Gas & Electronic Company v. Arizona Department of Revenue, et al. 

April 18, 2024 Case Summary: CV-23-0152-PR David Francisco, et al. v. Affiliated Urologists, LTD., et al.

April 9, 2024 Case Summary: CV-23-0181-PR Amy Silverman, et al. v. Arizona Department of Economic Security

March 19, 2024 Case Summary: CR-23-0137-PR State of Arizona v. Manuel David Perez-Gutierrez 

March 14, 2024 Case Summaries: CV-23-0208-PR Arizona Republican Party v. Stephen Richer/Adrian Fontes; CV-23-0233-PR Sherold D. Roaf v. Stephen S. Rebuck Consulting, LLC, dba Medstar Medical Transport, et al.

February 13, 2024 Case Summaries: CV-23-0130-PR Mark Gilmore, et al. v. Kate Gallego, et al.; CV-23-0211-PR Robert Vande Krol v. Superstition Fire & Medical/ Benchmark Insurance

January 23, 2024 Case Summaries: CV-23-0160-PR Reindon Quijada v Pimienta Dominguez; CV-23-0176-PR Dove Mountain, et al. v ADOR

January 16, 2024 Case Summaries: CR-23-0068-PR State of Arizona v. Bennett LaQuan Williams; CV-23-0085-PR Garbis Satamian v. Great Divide Insurance Co., et al.