2008 Case Summaries

These web pages are designed to provide members of the news media and other interested parties with summaries of Oral Arguments that will be or have been heard by the justices of the Arizona Supreme Court.

These summaries were prepared by the Arizona Supreme Court Staff Attorney’s Office and the Administrative Office of the Courts solely for educational purposes. They are not to be considered official commentaries by the court or any member thereof or part of any brief, memorandum or other pleading filed in these cases.

December 11, 2008 Case Summary: CV-08-0161-PR Arizona Minority Coalition For Fair Redistricting et al v. The Arizona Independent Redistricting Commission et al; CV-08-0225-PR Mayer Unified School District and Gadsden Elementary School District v. Mark Winkleman et al

December 9, 2008 Case Summary: CV-08-0252-PR Valerie M. v. ADES/Kaydee V./Randy V./Zachary V.; CV-08-0224-PR Laura Seisinger v. Scott Siebel, M.D.; CV-08-0189-PR Virgil Cain et al v. Tom Horne et al

November 6, 2008 Case Summaries: CV-08-0174-PR State of Arizona v. Raphael Durnan; CV-08-0159-PR City of Phoenix v. Mary Ann Perez et al

September 25, 2008 Case Summaries: CR-08-0033-PR State of Arizona v. Charles Eugene Smith; CV-08-0057-PR 1800 Ocotillo LLC v. The WLB Group Inc.

September 29, 2008 Case Summaries: CR-07-0412-PR State of Arizona v. Gary Douglas Peek; CR-08-0051-PR State of Arizona v. Marcel Barry Thomas

June 25, 2008 Case Summaries: CR-06-0295-AP State of Arizona v. Phillip Alan Bocharski; CR-05-0149-AP State of Arizona v. James Granvil Wallace; CV-08-0026-PR Steven H./Tammy H. v. ADES/Matthew H./Savannah H.; CR-06-0443-AP State of Arizona v. Shad Daniel Armstrong

May 20, 2008 Case Summaries: CV-07-0402-PR Michael Cullen v. Koty-Leavitt Insurance Agency, Inc., et al.; CR-07-0429-PR State of Arizona v. Hubert A. Stummer and Dennis A. Lumm; CV-07-0416-PR The Lofts At Fillmore Condominium Association v. Reliance Commercial Construction, Inc.

April 29, 2008 Case Summaries: CR-08-0001-PR State of Arizona v. Enis John Cheramie III; CR-05-0507-AP State of Arizona v. Cody James Martinez

April 24, 2008 Case Summary: CV-07-0412-PR First American Title Insurance Co v. Action Acquisitions, LLC and Free For Now, LLC

March 25, 2008 Case Summaries: CV-07-0265-PR Phoenix City Prosecutor's Office v. Hon. Ybarra/Joshua L. Landers; CV-07-0349-PR Hal Owens v. M. E. Schepp Limited Partnership

March 20, 2008 Case Summaries: CR-07-0319-PR State of Arizona v. Ann Mavinee Leenhouts; CV-07-0300-PR Town of Gilbert Prosecutor's Office v. Mitchell M. Matykiewicz

February 20, 2008 Case Summaries: CR-07-0227-PR State of Arizona v. Patricia A. Barnes; CR-04-0098-AP State of Arizona v. David Lamar Anthony

February 14, 2008 Case Summaries: CR-05-0163-AP State of Arizona v. John Montenegro Cruz; CV-07-0293-PR James L. Lee et al v. State of Arizona

January 15, 2008 Case Summaries: CV-07-0288-PR ADOR v. Action Marine/Randall et al.; CR-05-0174-AP State of Arizona v. Steve Alan Boggs

January 10, 2008 Case Summaries: CV-07-0280-PR Employers Mutual Casualty Co. v. DGG & Car Inc. et al; and CR-05-0508-AP State of Arizona v. Frank Dale McCray