2011 Case Summaries

These web pages are designed to provide members of the news media and other interested parties with summaries of Oral Arguments that will be or have been heard by the justices of the Arizona Supreme Court.

These summaries were prepared by the Arizona Supreme Court Staff Attorney’s Office and the Administrative Office of the Courts solely for educational purposes. They are not to be considered official commentaries by the court or any member thereof or part of any brief, memorandum or other pleading filed in these cases.

December 13, 2011 Case Summary: CR-09-0343-AP State of Arizona v. Brad Lee Nelson

December 6, 2011 Case Summaries: CV-11-0186-PR Era C. Nunez v. Professional Transit Management; CV-11-0150-PR City of Tucson v. State of Arizona et al

November 8, 2011 Case Summaries: CR-09-0253-AP State of Arizona v. Jahmari Ali Manuel; CR-11-0083-PR State of Arizona v. Pete J. VanWinkle; CR-11-0127-PR State of Arizona v. Patrick M. Ferrero

November 1, 2011 Case Summaries: CV-11-0072-PR CNL Hotels and Resorts et al v. Maricopa County; CR-09-0341-AP State of Arizona v. James Granvil Wallace

September 28, 2011 Case Summaries: CV-11-0028-PR Clifford J. Ochser v. Gerard Funk et al;
CR-11-0040-PR State of Arizona v. Douglas Lee Eddington; CV-11-0083-PR Pauline Cosper v. Marco & Flor Mora

September 22, 2011 Case Summaries: CV-10-0362-PR Martin Rivera-Longoria v. State of Arizona; CV-11-0091-CQ Julia Vasquez v. Saxon Mortgage Inc et al.

June 2, 2011 Case Summaries: CV-10-0300-PR Estate of Jacob Braden v. State of Arizona
CV-10-0397-PR Sue Lynn Craig v. Roger Thomas Craig

June 1, 2011 Case Summaries: CV-10-0336-PR Virginia Cox v. Ford Motor Co.;
CR-90-0356-AP State of Arizona v. James Lynn Styers; CR-09-0095-AP State of Arizona v. Scott Alan Lehr

May 3, 2011 Case Summaries: CV-10-0309-PR Ryan L. Jacobsen v. State of Arizona;
CV-11-0006-CQ Alfred Albano et al v. Shea Homes Limited Partnership et al

April 26, 2011 Case Summaries: CV-10-0324-PR American Asphalt & Grading Co v. CMX, LLC; CV-10-0339-PR Desert Mountain Properties v. Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Co

March 29, 2011 Case Summaries: CR-08-0025-AP State of Arizona v. Clarence W. Dixon;
CR-10-0306-PR State of Arizona v. Randall West and Penny West

March 22, 2011 Case Summaries: CR-10-0309-PR State of Arizona v. Michael Q. Hummons; CV-10-0327-PR Patricia Morehart v. State of Arizona and William C. Miller

February 23, 2011 Case Summaries:  CV-10-0292-PR Lettie Preston et al v. Kindred Hospitals et al; CR-10-0315-PR State of Arizona v. Laquinn A. Fischer; CR-09-0133-AP State of Arizona v. Donald D. Delahanty

February 15, 2011 Case Summaries: CV-10-0285-PR Jesus Gutierrez v. Masterson & Clark Framing, Inc.; CR-09-0019-AP State of Arizona v. Wayne Benoit Prince, Jr.

January 19, 2011 Case SummariesCV-10-0196-PR Leverage Land Co et al v. Michael W. Hodges et al; CV-10-0218-PR City of Peoria/Phoenix v. Brinks Home Security; CR-08-0200-AP State of Arizona v. Vincent Lee Accardo

January 18, 2011 Case Summary: CV-10-0405-SA Kirk D. Adams and Russell Pearce v. The Commission On Appellate Court Appointments et al.

January 11, 2011 Case Summaries: CR-10-0242-PR State of Arizona v. Louie Thomas Machado;  CV-10-0230-PR Amy Young v. Kenneth L. Beck