2012 Case Summaries

These web pages are designed to provide members of the news media and other interested parties with summaries of Oral Argument that will be or have been heard by the justices of the Arizona Supreme Court.

These summaries were prepared by the Arizona Supreme Court Staff Attorneys' Office and the Administrative Office of the Courts solely for educational purposes.  They are not to be considered official commentaries by the court or any member thereof or part of any brief, memorandum or other pleading filed in these cases.

December 18, 2012 Case Summaries: CR-10-0362-AP State of Arizona v. Edward James Rose; CV-12-0156-PR Ralph Thomas et ux v. Montelucia Villas, LLC

December 11, 2012 Case Summaries: CV-12-0149-PR Frank Hoffman v. State of Arizona; CR-10-0085-AP State of Arizona v. Manuel Ovante, Jr.

November 14, 2012 Case Summaries: CV-12-0120-PR In re the Estate of Fred N. Kirkes;
CV-12-0102-PR Robert Baker v. University Physicians Healthcare; CR-10-0358-AP State of Arizona v. Fabio Gomez

November 6, 2012 Case Summaries: CV-12-0211-PR James C. Sell v. Russell Sewell et al;
CV-12-0173-PR Vicki Pounders v. Enserch E&C et al; CR-10-0196-AP State of Arizona v. Steven John Parker

October 10, 2012 Case Summaries: CR-10-0052-AP State of Arizona v. Eric Boyston; CV-11-0358-PR Rae Ann Rumery et al v. Maria Baier/Doug Ducey

October 2, 2012 Case Summaries: CR-12-0018-PR State of Arizona v. Austin J. Bonfiglio; CV-12-0007-PR In Re the Estate of Mary A. Riley

June 12, 2012 Case Summaries: CR-09-0342-AP State of Arizona v. Isiah Patterson;
CR-09-0266-AP State of Arizona v. Scott D. Nordstrom; WC-11-0001-IR RE Water Rights to Gila/Little Colorado

June 11, 2012 Case Summaries: CR-09-0322-AP State of Arizona v. Pete J. VanWinkle; CR-09-0224-AP State of Arizona v. Rodney Eugene Hardy

June 5, 2012 Case Summaries: CR-10-0177-AP State of Arizona v. Gilbert Martinez, Sr.; CR-09-0199-AP State of Arizona v. Shawn Ryan Grell

May 8, 2012 Case Summaries:  CR-09-0077-AP State of Arizona v. Dale Shawn Hausner;
CR-10-0138-AP State of Arizona v. Ronnie Lovelle Joseph

May 1, 2012 Case Summaries: CV-11-0344-PR Mario W. et al v. State of Arizona; CR-11-0149-PR State of Arizona v. David Bernard Clark

April 3, 2012 Case Summary: CR-11-0314-PR State of Arizona v. Phil Gutierrez

March 27, 2012 Case Summaries: CV-11-0351-PR Ryan/Laetitia Coleman v. City of Mesa et al; CR-11-0282-PR State of Arizona v. Gary Wayne Gipson, Jr.

February 28, 2012 Case Summaries: CV-11-0273-PR Aaron Engler v. Gulf Interstate Engineering; CV-11-0291-PR State ex rel Horne v. Autozone

February 22, 2012 Case Summaries: CV-11-0308-PR BT Capital v. TD Service Co et al/Point Center; CV-11-0324-CQ American Family Mutual Insurance Co v. Sabine Sharp

January 24, 2012 Case Summaries: CV-11-0115-PR John F. Hogan v. Washington Mutual Bank et al; CR-09-0218-AP State of Arizona v. Benjamin Bernal Cota

January 18, 2012 Case Summaries: CV-11-0269-PR Sourcecorp Inc. v. Dean and Stacey Norcutt; CV-11-0198-PR Elizabeth Walsh et al v. Advanced Cardiac Specialists; CR-11-0180-PR State of Arizona v. Nelson Ivan Boteo-Flores